Ampophiles,
After nearly a decade of inactivity, I've decided to leap back into
ham radio with both feet. I'd like any and all input on choosing an
amp and am hoping this group will give me their rarely humble opinions
regarding some of my options. If your interested in the dirty details,
the background is at the end. Sorry if this is a little on the long side.
Any and all feedback is appreciated! Comments on vendors, new vs used,
internet vs hamfests, manufactures, etc are all welcome but I'm mainly
interested in "how much amp can I get for my $1000-$1400?"
A few of my choices:
1) AL-572: To me, this looks like a lot bang for the buck. $1229 at TexasTowers
QSK is optional - actually, I'm not exactly sure how badly I'd need QSK.
Four 572Bs, a relatively recent design incorporating a number improvements
over earlier amps. 1.3KW PEP
2) AL-80B: $1159 at TexasTowers; 1KW PEP, 800W CW
3) Used TenTec Centurion: 1.3KW PEP, 1KW CW, QSK, 2 3-500Zs
4) Used QRO HF-2000: 1200W CW or 1.5KW SSB
5) Used Alpha 99... might be kinda hard to find one in this price range.
6) Other... Tell me what I'm missing
My requirements:
* Price - I once heard that a rule of thumb was to spend about the same
on the amp as you spend on the rig. When I first heard this I laughed
thinking that it oversimplified the issue... but the more I think
about it, the more reasonable it sounds for some strange reason.
Anyway, I suppose I'm looking in the $1000 to $1400 range.
* Good reliability/performance for the price point. I'm a little worried
about what I've read for Amps like the AL-80 and AL-1500. Should I be?
Anyway, I don't want to frequently retube, nor spend a small fortune
when it is necessary to do so. Oh yeah, I'm not too keen on having a
ton of TVI reports either.
OPERATING REQUIREMENTS
* Relatively easy to use - I don't want to go through 30+ steps every
time I QSY 5kc. A no-tune, solid-state, computer controlled system
like the ACOM would be ideal, it's just WAY out of my price range.
I'd also like to invite guest op ham/relatives and friends over so,
I'll either need smarter relatives and friends or fairly idiot-proof
equipment. :)
* Definately CW, some phone, eventually digital modes.
* I'm going to try a contest or two without an amp, see what I think.
Eventually though, I'll try contesting with it. Kinda hard to tell at
this point.
* Years ago I was sort of a "casual DXer", so I suppose I will be again.
* It would sure be nice if I didn't have to drive it with 100W for >1KW.
BACKGROUND
==========
The XYL has been encouraging me to rekindle my interest in ham radio.
On the other hand, she's an accountant, so one of her first questions
was "how much is all of this going to cost?" With this in mind, I've
done a lot of research, drove to a ham store to look at rigs, and even
put together a spreadsheet with pricing info for the three phases.
Phase I is the basics (rig, wire antenna, ...), Phase II is the amp,
and Phase III is the tower/beam.
Phase I:
Icom IC-746 w/ FL100 500hz CW filter
Carolina Windom 160 Special
Computerized rig control.
Phase II:
A 1KW-1.5KW PA of some sort
Tuner capable of handling the PA
Phase III:
Trylon T500-56 56' free standing tower
Yaesu G-800SA rotor
Force 12 C4SXL 40-10m w/WARC (via tuner) Yagi or a Tennadyne/M2 LPDA
I'll probably work on setting up the shack itself (phase I) over the
next week or so. I'll probably get the amp in the next few months and
finally setup the tower next spring.
I applogize if this sort of thing is taboo on this maillist, but I
poked around the archives and found very little in the way of comparisons
between this this class of amplifiers.
Many thanks!
Pat, N0HR
--
FAQ on WWW: http://www.contesting.com/FAQ/amps
Submissions: amps@contesting.com
Administrative requests: amps-REQUEST@contesting.com
Problems: owner-amps@contesting.com
|