Hi Chris,
They brag about 65:1 swr survivability, but this is pulsed.
It's thermally limited. Basically this rating means that the FET can avalanche
safely if a high SWR results in high voltage pulses, and that it can handle high
current pulses too, without the bonding wires fusing. But certain high SWR
conditions result in a very high dissipated power, and in this regard the
survival of the FET depends on the total transient thermal resistance, and the
time the high SWR condition lasts.
So, the 65:1 SWR survivability is very welcome, because it gives your protection
circuit enough time to react. But it doesn't replace the protection circuit!
> Clearly a post
LPF reflectometer ref sample is necessary to shut it down with a poor match,
say above 2:1. But I see another pitfall; the switched LPFs being set to the
wrong band.
So, is the best solution adding another reflectometer after the output
transformer and prior to the filter to protect against that?
That's exactly what some commercially made amplifiers do. For example, download
and read the service manual for the Kenwood TL-120 amplifier. That's a 100 watt
add-on amplifier for the TS-120V QRP rig, made 35 years ago. That amplifier has
a forward/reflected power sensor after the filters, and an additional reflected
power sensor (no forward) before the filters. The service manual is explicit
about the protection circuit.
It's probably the simplest way to provide full protection.
> With an
expected third harmonic being 10-12 dB down at this point, the threshold
might need to be high, like 5:1 ...
Yes, but the SWR into the wrong filter is sky-high! So you don't need much
sensitivity there.
It's a good idea to couple a novel design feature to this protection circuit: A
robotic arm that comes out of the amplifier and slaps the operator, whenever he
selected the wrong band!
Manfred
========================
Visit my hobby homepage!
http://ludens.cl
========================
_______________________________________________
Amps mailing list
Amps@contesting.com
http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/amps
|