I wouldn't say I am an expert on the Alpha 87A although I did own one and
deal with issues inside it for several years. It was a good amp and its
best feature was the quiet and reliable PIN diodes making real QSK not only
possible, but normal. I never managed to kill mine. I did trade it in to
Alpha for a 9500. As far as PIN diodes are concerned, you can download the
SPEC sheet from Micro-Semi (UM4006D/SM) and for 1N4007s you can download the
Spec sheet from any company that makes them. UM4006D/SM PIN diodes run
about $16 per; 1N4007 diodes run about $0.03 per. So on price it ought to
be fairly obvious that there is a difference here. Looking at the spec
sheet, the speed of switching of the UM4006D is incredibly high (like 5
uSec) - the 1N4007 doesn't appear to be specified except to confirm that it
works well at 60 Hz. If 60Hz works for you - go for it. But this is a T/R
relay we are talking about and you don't want the power going to the wrong
place for very long. And 1/60 second is VERY long for 1500 Watts to be
going to the wrong place. (1/60 second = 16700 uSec).
>From what I have read, the failures tended to occur in earlier units due to
a less than optimal installation protocol during manufacturing. (10/05/2017
Amps Post from WC1M).
Microchip Technology Inc. appears to have units available for sale right now
- possibly others, and there appear to be alternates available.
I am enough of an expert to know that I would rather replace a dead part
with a same thing replacement than attempt to reengineer a critical circuit
that will kill my expensive transceiver in a few microseconds if I get it
wrong. Especially if the part costs less than $20. Good luck.
Dave W6DR
_______________________________________________
Amps mailing list
Amps@contesting.com
http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/amps
|