[Top] [All Lists]

handicapping vs. ratings

Subject: handicapping vs. ratings
From: hwardsil@seattleu.edu (Ward Silver)
Date: Sat Jun 5 10:22:00 1993
de Ward, N0AX
After surveying sport ratings/handicapping systems, it seems that handicapping
systems work best when the competition is held on a common playing area and
with very similar equipment for the competitors.  Examples of this type of
sport are bowling and golf.  Rating systems work better when events are distrib-
uted across long times or many locations.  Examples here are racing and chess.
It's pretty clear that given the variability of the circumstances for radio
contesters we fall into the latter category.

If, for purposes of argument only, we assume that a rating system is used, how
do we address the issues of guest operation and multi-op efforts?  My initial
suggestion would be to allow dual ratings for operator and station, much like
the old licensing system where you had an operator license and a station li-

See you in Field Day from W7FR on Whidbey Island (IOTA NA-069)

<Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread>
  • handicapping vs. ratings, Ward Silver <=