What happened to being content with participating and reaching personal
goals? This reminds me of sad youth sports situation when everyone gets a
trophy. I'm opposed to watering awards down. The categories are fine as they
are in my opinion. I want a trophy to mean something when I win it.
----- Original Message -----
From: "John Laney" <firstname.lastname@example.org>
Sent: Monday, April 11, 2005 6:59 PM
Subject: Re: [CQ-Contest] Let's change the ARRLDX rules
> I don't know that I favor a three band category for ARRL DX Contests. I
> like to encourage operating even on marginal bands, so I would probably
> prefer only an all band category. An all band or a single band
> alternative like ARRL has now is OK. It seems to work well for ARRL and
> CQ Contests.
> However, the SP DX Contest, run the first weekend in April each year,
> implemented for the first time this year a Three Band category. It is
> mixed mode only in this contest, which can otherwise be entered CW,
> Phone, or Mixed. The experience of the sponsors of that contest could
> tell us something about how that rule change was received. However, it
> is likely that not everyone noticed the change. For example, SOTB was
> not a category that could be chosen on the 3830 reporting page. I
> entered SOTB this year simply because I made contacts only on 15, 20,
> and 40. If I could have made (even one) QSO on 80 or 10, it would have
> been back to my favorite category, all band, mixed mode.
> John, K4BAI.
> CQ-Contest mailing list
CQ-Contest mailing list