The entire purpose of using phonetics is so the other guy gets your
information correct. I would only use standard phonetics in a DX contest,
where the other person may not speak very good English, but in a domestic
contest such as Sweepstakes I don't see any reason not to have some fun
AS LONG AS the other stations get my call correct.
I don't care what phonetics are used as long as I copy what you're trying
to communicate. For example, November Six Hot Chocolate worked quite well
at this end.
73, Zack W9SZ
On Sat, 21 Oct 2006, Dale Putnam wrote:
> Gee.... I wonder.... if I don't get the section... and I can't understand the
> = not standard = fony netics... then
> is it in my best interest to NIL the Q? And since I am the one that is
> responsible, not only for the content of what I am
> qsling for but also the integrity of my log.... then the issue becomes not
> only my responsibility to copy correctly but also
> the sending op is charged with sending so I can understand it. The downside..
> very simply put is NIL. And the upside
> very simply put, is learning how to exchange information in an efficient and
> orderly manner, with the least amount of time
> spent to get the job done.
> There are thousands of factors/excuses for not doing the job.... but NIL ends
> that discussion rather effectively. Don't do it
> right... don't get in log. No problem.... Ultimately... it is a team
> effort... and if one member of the team doesn't know how to
> play... then the team isn't as good as possible. So... precontest is the time
> to learn and study??????
> --... ...--Dale - WC7S in Wy
> > Date: Sat, 21 Oct 2006 04:02:07 -0700> From: firstname.lastname@example.org> To:
> > email@example.com> Subject: [CQ-Contest] Phonetics> > >People get
> > carried away with Phonetics.> > >For example, it is much easier to copy the
> > word Nebraska, say the whole> >thing, rather then "Ne" which some mush
> > mouths make it sound like "Me".> >Same for wasting time saying something
> > longer like November Echo instead of> >just saying Nebraska.> > >There are
> > only so many sections in SS. It is not heard to figure them out.> > >73,
> > Al> > True there are only so many sections?However why is it that every
> > year lots of people, mainly our friends south of the border, continue to
> > ask or assume that VO1 is MAR as opposed to NL? I have to correct many
> > times that it?s ?November Lima?, Newfoundland. While I appreciate the
> > challenges in knowing the sections for ones own country, let alone another
> > country with many more sections, ?I? prefer to be sent the sections
> > phonetically.> > Just my two cents worth, FWIW.>
> > > Dan Goodwin > > VO1MX VO2ZZ> > >
_______________________________________________> CQ-Contest mailing list>
> Check the weather nationwide with MSN Search: Try it now!
> CQ-Contest mailing list
CQ-Contest mailing list