CQ-Contest
[Top] [All Lists]

[CQ-Contest] cqww cw spotting report

To: "reflector cq-contest" <CQ-Contest@Contesting.COM>
Subject: [CQ-Contest] cqww cw spotting report
From: "K1TTT" <K1TTT@ARRL.NET>
Date: Thu, 04 Dec 2008 00:46:51 +0000
List-post: <cq-contest@contesting.com">mailto:cq-contest@contesting.com>
A big weekend for cw spots.  52745 spots in the database this time.  

The most spotted DX stations:

DX              Count
3X5A            645
HC8N            570
D4C             457
CT9L            365
PJ2T            334
TO4X            322
KP2M            308
8Q7DV           301
KH7X            252
HD2M            232
JA5FDJ  221
EE2W            219
OX5AA           214
V47NT           211
TO3R            209
DF0HQ           207

The busiest spotters:

Spotter count
AD6WL           618
K3LR-3  558
KC1XX           527
K8CC            520
N2NS            508
K6III           508
NQ4I            483
VE1DX           408
K1TTT-7 408

----------------------------------------------------------------------
Cheerleader report

What the columns mean:
Spotter = the spotting station
dx = the dx being spotted
spots = the number of spots the spotter made for the dx
total = the total number of spots the spotter made during the contest
pct = percentage of the total spots the spotter made for just that one dx
station.

spotter dx              Spots   Total   Pct
UA3TT           RT3T            33      53      62
E74WN           E77CFG  30      31      96
9A2D            E77CFG  22      22      100 
RK3TYA  RT3T            16      17      94
UA4HBW  TO3R            15      31      48
DL5DSM  CT9L            15      18      83
UU2JQ           4L0A            13      113     11
ZP5VAY  ZP0R            13      13      100
DF1LON  CT9L            13      136     9
4L5A            ZS4TX           13      37      35
FK8CP           FK8CP           13      13      100 (qsx 1838 + sked
freq????)

----------------------------------------------------------------------
Single spotter report

"Single Spotters" are stations who make only one dx spot in the whole
contest weekend.  It is obviously fairly unusual for a contest operator who
is active to make only one spot, many make 10's to 100's of spots during the
weekend.  It is common for DX'ers to make a single spot for a rare dx
station then turn off the radio, so lots of single spotters for rare
stations is common, but they also get lots of contest spots from other
stations.  The key here is the percentage of spots that are from 'single
spotters'.  A high percentage can be a sign of the use of fake callsigns to
spot yourself or a friend that you don't want to look like you are
cheerleading for... in any case, the use of fake callsigns is an obvious
sign of someone trying to deceive the world in one way or another.

What the columns mean:
DX - the dx station being spotted
Total - the total spots for them in the weekend
All(%) - the total number of single spots and the percentage of the total
dxs(%) - the number of the total spots that came from dxsummit and the
percentage of the total they are.  These are broken out because it is very
easy for someone to put in fake callsigns on dxsummit and it has been a
common source of abuse of the system.


DX              Total   All             DXS
3X5A            645     36(5%)  8(1%)
T31DX           105     26(24%) 10(9%)  (non-contest)
CY2ZT/2 39      23(58%) 23(58%)
UV2L            48      22(45%) 21(43%)
HC8N            570     20(3%)  4(0%)
J5UAP           76      18(23%) 3(3%) (non-contest)
HK1X            65      16(24%) 3(4%)
HD2M            232     15(6%)  10(4%)
OX5AA           214     14(6%)  3(1%)
5K0T            172     14(8%)  6(3%)
TO3R            209     13(6%)  6(2%)
KH7X            252     12(4%)  3(1%)
LZ9A            26      12(46%) 1(3%)
B4TB            69      12(17%) 11(15%)
D4C             457     12(2%)  3(0%)
VE2JCW  14      11(78%) 11(78%)

Ok, so as expected 3x5a who was very active got lots of spots, and out of
the 645 only 36 were from 'single spotters', this sets a good baseline to
start from.  CY2ZT/2, uv2l, hk1x, lz9a sure attracted a lot of single
spotters.  It is interesting that hk1x and lz9a got more from regular
clusters than from dxsummit, this is odd.  B4TB and VE2jcw attracted some
dxsummit single spotters also.

Note below that I have cut short the dxsummit data, they have switched to a
new site and I need to rewrite some of my processing stuff to make pretty
extracts, so just the spotter call and ip address are shown, and only some
examples from each one.

Ones that deserve a closer look are analyzed more below:

----------------------------------------------------------------------
CY2ZT/2 - dxsummit

IP Address: 69.41.173.145
Spotters: k3nn, f0cus, ve5sd, w1ll, h1ha, cl3ar, ve3ggh, w4car, ve4jy,
        w2vvo, nr2qq, kj8jj, k8uu, w5zi, k4aa, na7yy, aa3kk, n1ss, 
        k9ll, w8ii, k5vv, k5yy, w9uu, n2mm, f3jj, n2kk, aa8sz, k5vv, 
        n3zz, n6hh, ad4vv, k5vv, w5jj, aa3cc, k5vv, etc...

the pattern continues... all the same ip address, mostly with the same
last 2 letters.  The first row with f0cus, w1ll, h1ha, cl3ar were near
the end of the contest, then they get earlier and earlier, so near the
middle of the contest there were more of the double letter calls.  note
also that there are more spots than were flagged as single spotters, this
guy used k5vv a couple times, and i think repeated some others, and some
of his fake spots may have been real spotter calls that he duplicated.

The real odd part is that the ip comes back to:
OrgName:    1-800-HOSTING, Inc. 
OrgID:      1800H
Address:    3535 Travis Street
Address:    Suite 160
City:       Dallas
StateProv:  TX
PostalCode: 75204
Country:    US

or not really that odd I guess, someone has discovered a free demo of a web
anonymizer service.  so either cy2zt/2 was making spots himself, a friend
was trying to help anonymously, or someone was trying to make trouble for
him.


----------------------------------------------------------------------
uv2l - dxsummit

IP Address: 81.23.24.111, 81.23.24.104, 81.23.24.121, 82.23.24.110
Spotters:  2e0drd, m0cop, aa1v, g3kkp, k2te, uv2l, ek3sa, rw9wa, ea5cw,
        ua9tf, oy3je, f6dyx, pa3dbs, m0blf, rw2f, ua9ary, dl1et, dl8daz,
        io4t, rw6yu, etc, etc,

Yes, you read it right, he did spot himself... probably got the fields 
filled out backwards.  that is a hazard of doing that on dxsummit.

This one is more obvious, the ip comes back to:
role:           Kyivstar GSM
address:        Degtyarevskaya, 53
address:        Kiev, Ukraine


----------------------------------------------------------------------
hk1x - cluster

These were from a single cluster node:
 

OK1ER          200.6.184.196
K7OO           200.6.184.196
K8IU           200.6.170.228
JA2ERT         200.6.184.196
LY4R           200.6.184.196
OE4RT          200.6.184.196
K3ER           200.6.184.196
K9PL           200.6.184.196
K3LO           200.6.184.196
K9OI           200.6.184.196
JA2BBH         200.6.184.196
K8UY           200.6.184.196

which of course comes back to:

owner:       COSTAVISION S.A.ownerid:     CO-COSA20-LACNICresponsible:
Costavision S.Aaddress:     Avenida Principal El Bosque, Diagonal, 21,
48-35address:     BOLIVAR - Cartagena - BOcountry:     CO
----------------------------------------------------------------------
lz9a - cluster

These were all from a single cluster node also, each of these users made a
spot for lz9a:

29Nov2008@06:29:58 SV2BFG connected from 82.137.72.32
29Nov2008@17:35:39 F6GNU connected from 82.137.72.32
29Nov2008@04:55:47 IK2GFD connected from 82.137.72.32
29Nov2008@08:37:41 YO2LGD connected from 82.137.72.32
29Nov2008@07:34:48 DL1SBR connected from 82.137.72.32
29Nov2008@00:31:05 ON8SL connected from 82.137.72.32
30Nov2008@17:34:12 5B4AIZ connected from 82.137.72.32
30Nov2008@16:50:15 LZ2XP connected from 82.137.72.32
30Nov2008@17:54:47 LZ3SM connected from 82.137.72.32
30Nov2008@05:58:47 PY2KD connected from 82.137.72.32
30Nov2008@14:36:50 ZL2UO connected from 82.137.72.32

And the ip comes back to:
organisation:   ORG-RTCL1-RIPE
org-name:       Radio Telecommunications Company Ltd. / Mobikom
org-type:       LIR
address:        1 Jerysalem Street
address:        1784
address:        Sofia
address:        Bulgaria



----------------------------------------------------------------------
b4tb - dxsummit

IP Address: 222.191.211.20, 222.191.210.172
Spotters: wb6h, k5nv, on4awu, ua3wx, dl1dsm, sv1ukn, wb7y, jh7ucl,
        oz4rl, kg4rpx, wb3i, ok1dtq, oe8agh, ik1gnh, ly6v, swl, etc.

and that of course comes back to:
netname:      CHINANET-JS
descr:        CHINANET jiangsu province network
descr:        China Telecom
descr:        A12,Xin-Jie-Kou-Wai Street
descr:        Beijing 100088
country:      CN

----------------------------------------------------------------------
ve2jcw - dxsummit

IP Address: 96.20.169.76
Spotters: w3fr, ve2mce, n8rr, f5tte, w3bbg, w4gb, k3tc, swl, w3mm, 
        kc7ujf, cu4gb, k6yr, wb6yhg, w9pou, n6tg

also, ve2jcw spotted ve2xaa/2, 9q1ek,  from that ip

and the winner is:

OrgName:    Le Groupe Videotron Ltee 
OrgID:      VLCA
Address:    300 Viger Est
City:       Montreal
StateProv:  QC


----------------------------------------------------------------------
A special thanks to the two cluster sysops who responded quickly to my
request for ip addresses from the suspect spots.



A text copy and the raw data for this report is at:
http://www.k1ttt.net/logs/2008cqwwcw_spots.zip


David Robbins K1TTT
e-mail: mailto:k1ttt@arrl.net
web: http://www.k1ttt.net
AR-Cluster node: 145.69MHz or telnet://dxc.k1ttt.net
 



_______________________________________________
CQ-Contest mailing list
CQ-Contest@contesting.com
http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/cq-contest

<Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread>