[Top] [All Lists]

Re: [CQ-Contest] Leveling the palying field

To: Tom Haavisto <kamham69@gmail.com>
Subject: Re: [CQ-Contest] Leveling the palying field
From: Kevin Stockton <n5dx2005@yahoo.com>
Date: Wed, 22 Jun 2011 04:56:19 -0700 (PDT)
List-post: <cq-contest@contesting.com">mailto:cq-contest@contesting.com>
One thing I find interesting about this "Lets level the playing field"
discussion is that every serious contester works hard to make sure its
NOT a level playing field.  We try to gain the upper hand through
better/higher/more antennas, beams and anything else we can buy or
build that will "give us the edge we need" over the competition.  Same
thing in the shack - newer/better/quieter radios, magic boxes that we
think will help that little bit - all in an effort to win.

Sure - geography plays a part.  So does the operator skill, the
ionosphere and a hundred other variables - some under our control,
others not.  Add it all up, and even despite our best efforts -
sometimes we don't or can't win a certain competition.  Life's just
not fair sometimes.  What to do?  Well, we can give up, but that's too
easy!  A quitter can never win.

All of these things you mentioned are  the exact variables that should make a 
difference between who is in the  top ten, top three, or who is the winner.  
Operating a contest is fun,  but so is experimenting with a new antenna, or 
saving for a new radio,  or learning a new contest skill.  These are the 
differences that should  make a difference.  Take those away and we'll all be 
playing a video game, which would get real boring real quick.  Diving down into 
this rabbit hole is a Red Herring.  

This isn't only about winning the top spot.  Its about EVERYBODY having a  
CHANCE to compete in a DX contest in EVERY category.  More competition  will 
spur more motivation to build bigger stations and will increase  contest 

Bottom line - compete on your own terms.  If winning is so darned
important, and geography is standing in your way, then I guess you
need to move.  

The message to current and future  participants in the ARRL DX contest 
be that if you want to win  you need to move to the East Coast.   

Kevin, N5DX

CQ-Contest mailing list

<Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread>