[Top] [All Lists]

Re: [TowerTalk] QST(Readers) on drugs (was: 2006 Top Ten Chutzpah...)

To: "Ward Silver" <>,
Subject: Re: [TowerTalk] QST(Readers) on drugs (was: 2006 Top Ten Chutzpah...)
From: Bill Aycock <>
Date: Fri, 25 Aug 2006 14:49:04 -0500
List-post: <>
I thought I was nuts, looking through the August QST, then I went to the 
reading room (Dining room) and checked the SEPTEMBER  Issue- there it was!
Ward should be ashamed, he has an article in that same issue.

At 01:01 PM 8/24/2006 -0700, Ward Silver wrote:

> >
> > 1.  On p. 21 is something called a "fractal antenna" which appears to be a
> > weird 12 sided wood table top with a hole in the middle, hanging somehow
> > from something out of the picture.   What appear to be two legs of
> > undeterminable material protrude down from above.  The text says this is a
> > 600 foot long loop.  Maybe it's a joke?
>Actually, there has been quite a bit of work done on fractal antennas over
>the past ten years or so. (numerous IEEE Antenna society articles)  Your
>mobile phone or 802.11 equipment may use a fractal or near-fractal antenna.
>The antenna pictured apparently makes use of one of the more common fractal
>generators (algorithm) known as "Koch's Snowflake" to fold the loop in a
>repetitive way.  While the actual length of wire in the loop remains more or
>less the same as a full-sized antenna, the total area occupied by the loop
>is greatly reduced.  Unfortunately, the antenna's effectiveness is also
>reduced.  Some fractal generators do produce modest area reductions with a
>tolerable reduction in performance, but not in this rather extreme case.
>The poor performance is noted in the photo's caption, by the way.  Fields
>radiated by folded antennas are generally not as strong as those by a
>straight-line element because the fields from all the various segments tend
>to cancel and from other effects.
>2.  In Hints and Kinks on p. 55, someone has submitted what can only be
> > considered a Kink:  Use a plastic Budwig open wire feedline holder as a
> > mechanical means of effecting a transfer from unbalanced cable, to window
> > line.  No balun, no Z transformation of any type is in evidence.
>There are a number of ways to use a direct coax-to-parallel line connection,
>such as the G5RV antenna.  I would use some kind of a choke balun (beads,
>most likely) to keep the outside of the braid from becoming part of the
>antenna, but this is probably just a demo photo.  As far as the impedance
>discontinuity from the connector itself, the total electrical distance
>involved is a very small fraction of an HF wavelength, so the width of the
>Budwig is a non-issue.
>Neither of these appear to be worth the irritation they apparently caused.
>Try decaf, maybe?
>73, Ward N0AX
>TowerTalk mailing list

Bill Aycock - W4BSG
Woodville, Alabama 


TowerTalk mailing list

<Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread>