I fully agree, he will not improve above his stack of 2x3 elements with the
upper at 150 feet+:
If he has the upper at 150´and the lower on 65´his gain at 4° is 5dbs
higher, on 5° 3dbs higher and 2dbs higher up to 14°.
Putting the 5 element at 150´ would gain him about 2dbs above the stack on
the very low angles up to 13° but a null at 26° and would not be that much
flexible on propagation changes.
The 5 elements at 100´has a broader vertical lobe and still a lot of gain up
to 40° (like a dipol) which might be useful for close in contacts but is
worse for DX contests.
I simulated the differences above flat ground.
[mailto:email@example.com] On Behalf Of Rick Karlquist
More power to him, but my understanding from gurus such as N6BV and W3LPL is
that he would be better off with a stack of 3 element Yagi's. Possibly even
a stack of 2 element Yagi's would be better than one 5 element most of the
TowerTalk mailing list