Towertalk
[Top] [All Lists]

## Re: [TowerTalk] Square vs Round Holes

 To: Jim Lux Re: [TowerTalk] Square vs Round Holes David Gilbert Mon, 12 May 2008 17:18:34 -0700 mailto:towertalk@contesting.com>
 ```I agree. Calculating equivalences (round versus square) almost for sure requires a competent engineer, and it might even (maybe even probably) be significantly different depending upon location. For example, I'd bet that all of the factors Jim mentioned are relevant, but possibly in different weightings depending upon soil conditions. Since soil is, I believe, treated as a viscous liquid, the resistance to overturning may be treated differently in Florida than it is in Colorado. And in any case, I'd bet you have the same 2/3 factor between round and square (for viscous resistance) that you have for surface area of an antenna element in the wind. By the way, it isn't that as hams we can't (usually) come up with (mostly) workable solutions on our own, but when we're talking permit approvals and financial liability issues, it just doesn't make sense to me to guess. I'm all for a deep skinny round hole instead of a blocky rectangular one, but I don't think it would be trivial to convince anyone I had arrived at the proper dimensions on my own. 73, Dave AB7E Jim Lux wrote: > > Not necessarily. If the mass is being used as a "big weight in the > ground", then that's what's important. If it's for a free standing > tower, then it's mostly resisting the overturning moment, so long and > skinny is probably better than short and wide, for a given amount of > concrete, just because the lever arm is longer. (one deep piling > provides the same resistance as several horizontal pilings of the same > size, because it's direction independent). > > If the base is basically to "float" the downforce from the guys and > resist the shear force from wind on the tower, then big and flat might > work better... I don't know off hand. > _______________________________________________ _______________________________________________ TowerTalk mailing list TowerTalk@contesting.com http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/towertalk ```
 Current Thread [TowerTalk] Square vs Round Holes, Dino Darling Re: [TowerTalk] Square vs Round Holes, Daron Wilson Re: [TowerTalk] Square vs Round Holes, Jim Lux Re: [TowerTalk] Square vs Round Holes, David Gilbert <= Re: [TowerTalk] Square vs Round Holes, Its from Onion Re: [TowerTalk] Square vs Round Holes, Rick Karlquist Re: [TowerTalk] Square vs Round Holes, Dino Darling Re: [TowerTalk] Square vs Round Holes, K7LXC