Richard (Rick) Karlquist wrote:
> Joe Giacobello wrote:
>> If one had to install a ground mounted vertical as far as 2,000 feet
>> from the shack and wanted to avoid the expense of using low loss coax,
>> could a balanced feedline be used as an alternative? The idea would be
>> to run the balanced feed line to the base of the antenna and connect to
>> the antenna through a current balun. The input to the feedline and the
>> antenna would be matched by means of a balanced tuner in the shack.
>>
>>lower loss than the hardline. You can look at aluminum wire vs copper.
> It's just a cost thing. Physics vs money.
>
> I happen to have used 4 AWG insulated stranded aluminum. Evidently,
> the insulation and stranding haven't hurt me in the loss department,
> as the loss is close to the theoretical loss, which is in the tenths
> of a dB on the low bands.
>
I would think that given the half mile run, you should give serious
thought to aluminum (unless someone gives you the mile of copper wire)
or copperclad steel (depending on the frequency.. as long as the skin
depth is much less than the cladding thickness). Maybe even aluminum
clad steel. Aluminum is about 60% the conductivity of copper, so
considering it as a "tube", if you go 60% bigger diameter, you'll have
the same loss. Whether buying 2.5 times the volume of aluminum is
cheaper is something you'll have to check. On a raw materials basis,
almost certainly, but wire prices only follow metal prices on a lagging
basis, and because so much copper wire is used, there are anomalies.
(Copper/Aluminum density 9/2.7.. about 3.. Copper price is about $2/lb,
aluminum about $0.65/lb.. also about 3, so for the same volume, copper
costs 9 times what aluminum does. For the same loss, aluminum will cost
about 1/3 what copper does)
I second Rick's comment about tuning at the antenna... and maybe you
could figure out a matching network that does the transformation to your
open wire line impedance, rather than transforming to 50 ohms, then from
50 to 450 or 50:800. You'll still need a transformer at the shack,
probably (or, you could use your tuner to do the transformation..)
_______________________________________________
_______________________________________________
TowerTalk mailing list
TowerTalk@contesting.com
http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/towertalk
|