[Top] [All Lists]

Re: [TowerTalk] who's "right" (a tuner question)

To: jim feldman <>,
Subject: Re: [TowerTalk] who's "right" (a tuner question)
From: Grant Saviers <>
Date: Mon, 06 Dec 2010 11:18:35 -0800
List-post: <">>
Your MFJ may not be "hosed" because it is sensitive to other frequency 
RF as it energy detects broad-banded.  Mine is unusable on antennas 
because of a 50kw AM band tower about 1 mile away.  OTOH my AIM4170 
handles the same situation with just an small noise blip which easily 
averages out.

Grant KZ1W

On 12/6/2010 10:30 AM, jim feldman wrote:
> The cast of players: Kenwood TS-940, Heath SA 2060 ant. tuner, MFJ 259.  I
> was trying to use the MFJ to create a table of settings for the tuner.  Just
> wasn't working (never could find a SWR much lower than say 1.8:1).  After
> further reading, I tried the noise peaking method with C.out at max, at
> about half and I dialed in L from the bottom.  Once I had that (which got me
> surprisingly close), I turned the 940 power all the way down (around 10w),
> set the output to cw, hit transmit (after a quick ID) and dialed in a near
> 1:1 match in any band between 75-15.  The TS-940 SWR readings were pretty
> close to the meter on the tuner.
> So who's right and why?  In one corner we have the transmitter and tuner.
> Close enough I'd consider them the same.  Should I prefer the tuner reading?
>   In the other corner, we have the MFJ that wasn't even in the same ballpark.
>   Is it hosed?  I had it cabled to the tuner input for testing purposes.  Is
> it because of the low output of the MFJ?  I swapped around all cables except
> the output to the antenna.  Put fresh cells in the MFJ.
> All connections were either RG8x (foil and braid) or RG213 except LMR400 out
> to the trapped vertical antenna. Yes, I'm aware of the efficiency issues
> here, but I'm on a small suburban lot with 35ft height restrictions and a YL
> who tolerates (just) my "metal pokey things" in her garden.
> thanks
> jim (w6jmf)
> _______________________________________________
> _______________________________________________
> TowerTalk mailing list

TowerTalk mailing list

<Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread>