On 11/17/12 6:32 PM, K8RI wrote:
On 11/17/2012 10:51 AM, Jim Lux wrote:
On 11/17/12 4:40 AM, K1TTT wrote:
Dale - WD4IFR
In any lightning strike, even a 2" solid piece of copper takes on the
characteristics of a light bulb filament.
I've never seen a conductor melt that has take a lightning strike here.
It is simple statements like this that make the rest of what you say
questionable. The fact is that MOST lightning strokes hitting even
conductors will not significantly heat them. To get any significant
in 2" copper is probably even beyond even the largest measured mega
I'm not sure I'd go quite that far as I've seen holes blown right
through the wings of large aircraft from mega strokes.
Aluminum melts at a MUCH lower temperature than copper (660 vs 1085) AND
a lower density (so temperature rise for a given amount of energy, in
the same volume, is higher).
When doing exploding wires, I did a lot of aluminum wires for this reason.
I agree... take a look at the Preece or Onderdonk equations for fusing
current. Onderdonk takes into account the pulse length.
Many lightning strikes are a repetition of strokes that add up to
substantial time (relative to the length of a single stroke). Yet I have
The current is a summation of a rather complex wave form with relatively
steep rise and fall times. Most strikes with thousands of peak amps
20-50kA peak. 2 us rise (10%-90%), 50 us fall to 50%
probably have less than a hundred amps average for less than one second.
(I'd guess at less than a 1/4 second for the event) If you are
calculating fuse time, how can you not take into account duration which
would be a summation of the current wave form for the duration of the
event. IE you need to know how many jouls the fuse can stand for a
It's actually called the "action", which is basically the integral of
I^2*t (combined with the resistance of the conductor, that turns into
joules, which is what melts the metal). So, it's really the peak
current that's important, because that's the squared term, more than the
But in any case, there are well known relationships for lightning that
cover the multiple pulses over time issue.
TowerTalk mailing list