Under the current CQWW rules, that log snippet looks perfectly legitimate. They
were CQing on 14099 and doing S&P for the other QSO's. That could have been
done
with a single radio, with the bandmap being loaded with DX spots, or it could
have been done with a second radio, and a lockout to prevent both radios from
transmitting on the same band at the same time.
I simply don't see a problem here.
73,
Steve, N2IC
Andrei Stchislenok wrote:
> Seems to me that several logs are merged here...
>
> They DO need an Station Inspector during the Contest over there :)
>
> 2009/8/22 brian coyne <g4odv@yahoo.co.uk>
>
>> I have been looking at some old CQWW CW logs for hints and tips, to
>> discover how some of the top guns operate.
>>
>> In some of them I came across apparantly glaring anomolies which did not
>> accord with my understanding of the M/S rules.
>> However after following the thread on here 'Why The 10 min rule anyway'I
>> realised that I had it all wrong and it is a case of
>> 'if it isn't specifically excluded by the wording of the rules then it's
>> ok,' - anything goes.
>>
>> For a nation which has the highest number of lawyers in the world in it's
>> population, probably by numbers as well as per capita, I find it bewildering
>> that CQWW Committee cannot come up with a rule which would govern their
>> intent!
>>
>> Be that as it may I will come to the point of this post....
>>
>> Below is a log extract from a top M/S contender. It covers a period of 4
>> minutes and, ignoring the contact in the 32nd minute, records 20 qso's.
>> The run freq is 14099, there was one mlt on 21mhz, ignoring that one I make
>> that to be 10 frequency changes on 14mhz in that time period. Wow that's
>> some going, 5 q's per minute, 10 frq changes, plus a mlt....
>> but wait, see how the times jump around? does that mean merged logs, why
>> would there need to be merged logs same band, could it be two transmitters
>> same band? Well I never!
>>
>> IMO, and many others too, the M/S has become a joke, merge it with the M/2,
>> or change the rules to one transciever and one receiver connected up at one
>> time, the spotting station to have no mic or key available.
>> At least then the Station Inspector would know what he is looking for,
>> strikes me otherwise he has no chance of knowing what is going on, with
>> regard to this section of the rules anyway.
>>
>> All the best,
>>
>> Brian 5B4AIZ (C4Z).
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>> QSO: 14039 CW 200-11-25 1328
>> QSO: 14099 CW 200-11-25 1328
>> QSO: 14102 CW 200-11-25 1328
>> QSO: 14099 CW 200-11-25 1328
>> QSO: 14099 CW 200-11-25 1328
>> QSO: 14065 CW 200-11-25 1329
>> QSO: 14099 CW 200-11-25 1328
>> QSO: 14099 CW 200-11-25 1329
>> QSO: 14114 CW 200-11-25 1330
>> QSO: 14099 CW 200-11-25 1329
>> QSO: 14099 CW 200-11-25 1329
>> QSO: 14099 CW 200-11-25 1330
>> QSO: 21034 CW 200-11-25 1329
>> QSO: 14099 CW 200-11-25 1330
>> QSO: 14058 CW 200-11-25 1331
>> QSO: 14099 CW 200-11-25 1330
>> QSO: 14099 CW 200-11-25 1331
>> QSO: 14099 CW 2007-11-25 1331
>> QSO: 14028 CW 2007-11-25 1332
>> QSO: 14099 CW 2007-11-25 1331
>> QSO: 14099 CW 2007-11-25 1331
>>
>>
>>
>> _______________________________________________
>> CQ-Contest mailing list
>> CQ-Contest@contesting.com
>> http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/cq-contest
>>
>
>
>
_______________________________________________
CQ-Contest mailing list
CQ-Contest@contesting.com
http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/cq-contest
|