Topband
[Top] [All Lists]

Topband: A/B Testing Limits - Good Stuff!

To: <topband@contesting.com>
Subject: Topband: A/B Testing Limits - Good Stuff!
From: smlx at earthlink.net (Steve Lawrence)
Date: Wed Jun 25 15:14:41 2003
As DXers and consumers of commercial radios, I believe that our demands 
have driven the state of the art for years, especially in receiver 
design. As in all commercial products, performance is always expected 
to be the same (within reasonable tolerances) from one unit to the 
next, right out of the box. (EG - VCR / DVD tracking; amateur 
antennas.) Otherwise, the market place will deal a swift blow to the 
product if not the company. So while some might question the validity 
of tests on a single unit, if that one unit doesn't represent what you 
might reasonably expect to get right out of the box, then what 
credibility does the manufacturer's product claims have? We all love to 
tweak, but the baseline, out of the box unit should always be 
predictable.

That consistently good comments come from a variety of users about the 
K2, TS-830, FT1000D, MP etc. and not so flattering remarks appear about 
others, speaks volumes. At least to me.

There is nothing stopping anyone who believes that their radio has been 
wronged from performing their own tests.

It's exactly tests and comparisons like K6SE's that, for astute 
designers and manufacturers, will result in product improvements that 
will benefit us all.

I, for one, look forward to Earl's continuing results.

73, Steve WB6RSE

<Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread>