Greg —
Your aluminum foil fix possibly eliminates direct radiation (from the SSD) as
the noise source, but says nothing about conducted noise from the power cord
(or other cables going in and out) of the desktop system.
If SSDs impose totally different current (pulse) requirements on the desktop's
power supply, it's entirely possible you'd have a different RFI scenario on the
power cord if it has inadequate filtering to begin with. Putting cores on the
SATA cable only affects common-mode currents ON THAT CABLE — it does nothing
for common-mode currents exiting the desktop via other cables. The
SSD-specific power supply currents are differential mode between the power
supply and the SSD itself, but can cause common-mode RFI emissions if the power
supply does not have adequate filtering at the power cord's point of entry or
to other cables in/out of the desktop chassis.
Also, you might want to look at whether SSD maximum current pulses are too much
for your desktop's PS to handle, thus causing the PS to go into an abnormal
state at some fairly repetitive switching rate. That's assuming your SSD is
powered from your desktop's internal PS.
If the SSD is an outboard unit with its own power supply, shielding the SSD
itself will be useless if there's a power cable running between the SSD and a
wall-wart, for instance.
Bud, W2RU
On Jun 26, 2012, at 6:36 AM, Greg Chartrand wrote:
> Last month I began a computer up-grade process at home and work by using
> solid state drives (SSD) in both laptop and desktop systems. The upgrades
> have been very successful providing a significant performance increase and
> extended battery life.
> The last upgrade was my ham shack desktop system that I rebuilt with a new
> copy of Windows 7. All seemed well until I turned the rig on and heard
> garbage and multiple birdies across the lower 50 khz on 160.
> I was distracted for a week trying to recover a lost disk but I put the SSD
> in place again yesterday. This time I wrapped the SSD in aluminium foil and
> put 2 clamp on cores on the SATA cable. I fired up my system, and the extra
> measures had no noticeable improvement on the birdie situation. The
> birdies appear as soon as I power up the drive.
> I doubt if I will be able to remove the noise so this is a warning to those
> who may consider the same upgrade to their hamshack computer. My computer
> with the old fashion Hitachi hard drive contributes zero noise to my
> receiving capability on any band so SSD's are not in my future!
> Greg
_______________________________________________
UR RST IS ... ... ..9 QSB QSB - hw? BK
|