Hi Pete,
> I have a Round Emblem model. I was told that the RF cable
used to connect
> the Xmiter (KWM2 etc) to the input of the 30L1 was of critical length. It
> was explained that the Amp could go into runaway on 21 Mhz and above if
> this cable was not used.
Your problem illustrates my point about the grid system in the 30L1,
and the silly super cathode driven system applied to triodes.
The 30L1 lacks two things important for stability, it has the grids
improperly grounded and it has NO neutralization circuit. Both are
serious mistakes with four 811A tubes in parallel.
You can see, if you read the post I made on a single 811A, that the
transmission loss through a single tube is only 25 or 26 dB on 30
MHz, with four tubes in parallel the problem is at least six dB
worse. It is very easy and almost guaranteed feedback can exceed gain
under some load and source conditions.
Anyone owning a Dentron Clipperton L can see the same thing, remove
the exciter (sometimes not necessary), key the PA, rotate the
controls, and the amplifier oscillates on ten and 15 meters.
Good design dictates ANY PA should be totally stable under any tuning
condition with any type of termination on the input and output at
extremes of supply voltages. Four un-neutralized 811A's (or even two
572B's, like the Yaesu FL-2100) will fail this test quite often.
The long cable is a band-aid for this stability problem, the cable
loss hopefully gets the amps input terminate well enough to improve
stability.
The real fix would be to properly bypass the grids and neutralize the
tubes, or if that is too tough, add some form of attenuator
between the tuned input and the tubes. It would be necessary to
add enough additional loss (close to the tubes) in addition to the
system's feedback loss so overall gain does not exceed the feedback
loss under ANY load or source condition. Only if gain exceeds
feedback loss (and feedback is the correct phase) will the PA
oscillate.
I prefer neutralization, since it also improves efficiency, but
either method will improve IMD performance and stability.
811's and 572's are a pretty unstable tube.
> I was told that the designers of this Amp were under the gun to make ship
> dates and had a problem with ( ???) above 15 meters. The Air Force wanted
> the Amp ASAP ..the designers found that the 20.5 FT cable helped reduce
> "the problem"
Even Gonset neutralized their 811A's, so did Heath. Collins must have
been in a hurry, because they had some VERY good engineers.
73, Tom W8JI
--
FAQ on WWW: http://www.contesting.com/ampfaq.html
Submissions: amps@contesting.com
Administrative requests: amps-REQUEST@contesting.com
Problems: owner-amps@contesting.com
|