I'd have to agree with Denny. The MkV Field with Inrad roofing filter
is probably the next best to an Orion or Omni6/roofing filter
combination. Phil, if you're getting "murdered" by overload with MkV
Field, I'd first check that the receiver is adjusted properly as Denny
suggested.
All that being said, there's no question that you'll get less
"murdered" with the Orion, and suffer less gray matter damage during a
brutal 48-hour contest.
73,
Barry N1EU
n1eu.com
On 12/7/06, Dennis OConnor <ad4hk2004@yahoo.com> wrote:
Phil, the short answer is -10dB worse to +10dB better... The long answer is it
depends on the details...
I have the MK-V with the Inrad roofing filter and a full filter set <I have never
used a Field model> and the OII with a full filter set, and a 6+ (564) with the
Inrad CW roofing filter and a full filter set... These are outstanding DX and
contest radios... A $20,000 RACAL cannot do what these radios do in the contesting
environment...And, I feel the receiver on the OII is superior to the MK-V and the
6+...
Does that mean I can work signals on the OII I can't even hear on the MK-V or
the 6+? The answer is no... But in heavy qrm I can puzzle out the call or the
exchange faster on the OII - personal opinion... And 'maybe' I can work a qsb
signal that is just at the noise level, with heavy static crashes, on the OII
that I could not with the others - maybe not... The devil here, is in the
details...
If you just plug in a MK-V or an OII, turn em on and go for it, you are not likely to
hear any difference - you will get killed in heavy QRM... You need to select the
best filter / bandwidth for the conditions <once in a while in really vicious qrm
going way wide will allow you to copy what you can't on the narrow filter, always
worth a few seconds trial>... You need to turn off the AGC and the Preamp... You
need to use Attenuation and the RF Gain control to avoid overloading the IF stages...
You need to set the audio to a comfortable level and the RF Gain becomes your main
volume control.... You need to get used to using IF shift - just a little goes a long
ways - and on CW, switching sidebands is another tool... Having a receive-only
antenna is a must at times on the lower bands... And having done all this you need to
condition that filter between your ears - ten pushups (contacts) every day to tone
the muscle and hit every contest on the weekends even if only for an
hour, as a cardio workout...
And there are times when the qrm is laid on top that elusive dx signal in
layers and there is just nothing you can do about it... The guys you hear
working the DX through the qrm are in a different geographic area, are hearing
different levels of qrm than you, and have antennas with different patterns
than yours - apples and oranges and nothing you can do will change that....
Now, I would love to tell you that buying an OII will solve all your problems, but I
can't... I made the decision only after long and careful thought and monitoring the
various whine, errrrr, chat groups.... Before you deep six the MK-Vconsider
spending the money to outfit it with narrow filters and spend time doing the things i
have outlined <if you haven't already - if you have, then just plonk me :>..
Bottom line; I am very happy with my OII and glad I bought it... ymmv...
|