I think that’s what I mentioned also....
It all depends on how your antenna can be sited in relation to the areas of
interest, which is one of the things we go over in an overview document that
helps new hams get started thinking about what will work for them at their
site. If your best or only support trees would put the 45 degree null in the
azimuth pattern (resulting from using the 40M element on 15M) toward Europe, it
might not be a good compromise. It isn’t that much work to add the fourth
wire, as long as you realize that if the resonant frequency doesn’t change when
you tune the 15M element, you need to slightly lengthen the 40M element.
Steve, W3AHL
From: Larry Loen
Sent: Sunday, April 26, 2015 5:41 PM
To: Steve, W3AHL
Cc: TowerTalk
Subject: Re: [TowerTalk] Fan/Parallel Dipoles
One way of dealing with 15 is to just use an antenna tuner which basically
reuses the 40m dipole as a 3/2 wavelength antenna. You then just do 40/20/10
and have only three lines to worry about. You don't even have to tune 15
separately. I have done this and it works well. It simplifies construction,
tuning, and deployment. Pattern is a little different on 15, but I have found
it effective.
Larry WO7R
On Sun, Apr 26, 2015 at 2:29 PM, Steve, W3AHL <w3ahl@att.net> wrote:
Parallel multi-band dipoles require some attention to detail during
construction and tuning, but they certainly are a good solution for many sites.
I have hosted several antenna building parties for our local club where we
have successfully completed almost 30 antennas, in a wide variety of band
configurations and wire types. Four bands are the most I recommend, but we
have built several five bands antennas that tuned fine. Many were built by new
hams that hadn’t gotten on HF yet, due to the lack of an antenna. After the
antenna is tuned, another mini-party is usually scheduled to help get it up in
the air at owners site.
All will cover the entire band (for 40-10M) at less than about 2.5:1 VSWR,
except on 80M, assuming a reasonable height (40-70+ ft.). We try to tune them
at the height and vertex angle for the final site, but sometimes a little
tweaking is needed at the final installation site, especially on 15 and 10M
when mounted as an inverted V. Tuning is done with an AIM-470C, allowing the
owner to have a record of what the tuning was for future reference. I usually
include an EZNEC plot for azimuth and elevation patterns and sometimes an HFTA
example of how their site affects the pattern in key directions.
Tuning is fairly straightforward if the antenna is built correctly and
measured accurately. Start with the longest elements first and work your way
down. Tuning the shorter elements will not affect the longer ones. One
problem to be aware of is the interaction between 40 and 15M elements,
especially if 40M is tuned a little high to favor the upper part of the band.
It can make tuning 15M very frustrating, until 40M is tuned just a little
lower. Yes, you can operate 15M using the 40M element at its third harmonic if
you use a tuner and don’t mind the nulls in the pattern.
They make a good club project, since it really helps to have someone on the
team that has built and tuned one before! The most critical part is getting
the wires dressed correctly where they fan out from the feed point. The
hardest part is getting people to follow the directions carefully and measuring
the wire accurately so the two sides stay balanced as they are tuned. It is
hard to build one by cutting the wires to length from a table and expecting it
to centered in the desired band. I find that 6” spacing between elements work
well. A four-band 75/40/20/10 antenna can be built for less than $40, plus
feed line and supporting ropes, pulleys, etc. It takes 4-8 hours to build and
tune (with 2-3 people helping for some parts of the project) depending on
experience level and how much time everyone spends chatting (antenna parties
tend to be social events!).
While just about any piece of wire can be made to work to many operators’
satisfaction, dipoles always seem to perform more consistently, produce less
RFI in the shack and can run the legal limit without a tuner in most cases, at
least for me.
Steve, W3AHL
_______________________________________________
_______________________________________________
TowerTalk mailing list
TowerTalk@contesting.com
http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/towertalk
_______________________________________________
_______________________________________________
TowerTalk mailing list
TowerTalk@contesting.com
http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/towertalk
|