2.) #10, ignoring connection imperfections, has about .01 ohms per 10 ft.
That's up to 0.2volts with 20 amps of power supply loop current.
Not a problem unless you have bonded DC- to the power supply chassis.
Bingo.
Virtually EVERY piece of gear has a bonded negative to chassis. The whole
concept is screwed up, especially negative lead fuses, but it is what it is.
No one can force the industry to float negative grounds from chassis. Even
RF transistors have the metal bases tied to emitters, which forces a
negative ground to heatsinks unless the designer can seriously compromise
cooling.
Also, almost every Ham radio manufacturer in the world isolates the low
level audio shields inside radios except at one point because they are
well aware of issues with the large currents in 12V solid state high
power systems.
Yep. It's called "The Pin One Problem," and is a well documented cause of
hum, buzz, and RFI.
...and no matter how much we idealize the situation in our minds, we cannot
change the population and things we cannot change just because we dislike a
$2 transformer for some reason.
>> Ham stations have grounds, and those grounds cannot be bonded
perfectly to the mains, nor will many people bond them at all.
WRONG! We MUST bond all grounds in a facility for lightning safety, and
for safety of personnel. And when done completely and properly, it SOLVES
problems.
We cannot force the world to do things that are difficult, expensive, and/or
inconvenient.
Because of that, we have to move away from the theoretically ideal world of
zero ground potential difference and face the way the world really works.
Very few people are going to bond grounds properly, and fewer still will
drill into a computer or other equipment to add a ground lugs or modify
equipment to float negative returns from chassis.
The only thing eliminating the isolation transformer does, other than saving
$2, is ruin systems in the real world. It is a terrible suggestion. No
accessory manufacturer will ever follow your directive.
As an example, when MFJ designed the voice keyer they "cheaped out" or
neglected the isolation transformer. About 80%-90% of the units came back
from audio distortion and "RF" problems. They came to me, and I redid the
layout with a simple $1.10 audio transformer and low frequency floating
shield system. Complaints vanished.
Now I could have written a letter like this:
"Dear Customer,
Because we have some opposition to using $1.10 isolation transformers, we
would like you to rewire your station. Please do the following:
1.) Never ground the case of the VK to anything except a perfect station
ground buss that is not common with the main supply
2.) Never power the VK from the station supply. Always use a DC filtered
ground independent wall wart
3.) Never allow the case to contact any other metal or conductors in the
shack
4.) MFJ is not liable for any damage to the radio mic input circuit by
accidental grounding of the + power supply lead
Sincerely, MFJ"
....but silly me, I went ahead and added the transformer so they could
pretty much connect it any way they like without blowing up their radio or
having distortion.
73 Tom
_________________
Topband Reflector Archives - http://www.contesting.com/_topband
|