[AMPS] neutralization

[Ian White, G3SEK]

Carl, KM1H wrote:

[many snips] 

>>Gary Coffman posted the analysis in r.r.a.homebrew several months ago.
>>I'll try for one last time.
>
>Who is Gary Coffman??  If his information  was so good, please repost it
>here for us that dont spend our lives on the Internet. 

KE4ZV. I will leave the detailed search to you, since you don't have to
pay the phone company by the second for on-line time.

Go to Rich's web site and take the link to the archive of the
r.r.a.homebrew discussions (pages of W6???). You'll find it there. 

Alternatively, try my posting again with a fixed-space (non-
proportional) font.

Also, go and look at N7WS's measurements, and at his own interpretation
of them. The measurements that you say ought to be done, he has done
already.

>>
>>What comes out is that if Rp in the suppressor is high, Re in the
>>equivalent parallel network is LOW. There is an impedance *INVERSION*! 
>
>Of course there is an Inversion if you and others continually insist on
>mixing Parallel and Series circuits.  

It's not I who insist in mixing them - they're mixed in the real-life
circuit. To understand what's happening, they need to be straightened
out so that everything is in the same form.


>Why not just ask Rich to clarify
>his statements instead of pontificating?  We can not all be experts in
>Engineering, Linguistics and Semantics at the same time....some of us
>work for a living. 
>

>
>
>As an author you have a VERY PROFESSIONAL stake in this Ian; information
>to the contrary could affect your book sales. 
>

The only thing that could affect my book sales would be giving other
people bad information. That's why I still want to know the real story
about this.

Carl, thank you for reminding me that I work for a living too, freelance
and and mostly paid by the hour. This subject is not earning me any
money; it's interesting, but it's a time-sink. 

I literally can't afford any more of this, so I'm outta here.


73 from Ian G3SEK          Editor, 'The VHF/UHF DX Book'
                          'In Practice' columnist for RadCom (RSGB)

--
FAQ on WWW:               http://www.contesting.com/ampfaq.html
Submissions:              amps@contesting.com
Administrative requests:  amps-REQUEST@contesting.com
Problems:                 owner-amps@contesting.com