[Amps] Grid protection resistors
Tom W8JI
w8ji at w8ji.com
Mon Jun 26 16:46:57 EDT 2006
By the way, NEVER use a resistor to protect sensitive
expensive devices.
Fuses are bad enough. They have a very slow failure period
as they melt and then open. The time is also dependent on
temperature and even the age of the fuse, but it can be a
very long time at 200% overload.
The grid often will protect a fuse, rather than a fuse
protecting a grid.
Anyone who understands anything about resistors would also
know a metal film resistor can take a pretty severe overload
before opening. It isn't anywhere remotely as good as a
fuse, and fuses are bad enough that they should be avoided.
The best system without any question is a solid state system
that drives a fast relay. Instead of a dozen seconds it can
open in a dozen milliseconds or faster, and the cut out
point is very well defined.
There are many more good and easily verified or common sense
reasons to avoid a fuse or worse yet a resistor for grid
protection, but the fact the tube would have virtually no
protection under most overload conditions is probably good
enough.
73 Tom
More information about the Amps
mailing list