[Amps] {Collins} Understanding Screen Current in a Tetrode
Roger (K8RI)
k8ri at rogerhalstead.com
Wed Jan 28 03:56:27 EST 2015
On 1/27/2015 9:26 PM, Carl wrote:
> I don't care for that JI answer since grid driven tetrodes are almost
> always run in AB1 where there is no grid current and in AB2 there is
> only a flicker of current on peaks but a lot more IMD. Tuning is via
> the screen and power meters and let the mike gain control take care of
> the grid. Just remember that AB1 is less efficient than AB2 or B...or
> C for that matter
Agreed. Most of the Tetrodes I've seen used at ham power levels and a
bit beyond like the 4CX100, 4CX1500B, FU728F and others exhibit negative
screen current with low drive, but around a KW out, (more or less) they
go to positive screen current. At that point you tune and retune for
maximum screen current while staying within the manufacturers ratings.
At-any-rate, "in general", you tune for max output as you increase drive
until positive screen is observed, You then tune for max screen current
with plate tuning and loading (while staying within the rating of the
tube) as you increase drive. None of the ones I use goes beyond AB1 so
no grid current is present. A tiny amount of grid current shuts them down,.
Few really worry about efficiency any more as the power limit is based
on output regardless of mode. OTOH when running Class AB1 rather than
AB2 the amount of heat dissipated can be quite high. In class A it's
enough to heat a good size shack in mid winter. IE, at 1500 out @25%
(class A) efficiency it takes around 6,000 watts input -1500, or 4500
watts of heat out. That's a lot of heat and requires a lot of air at a
pretty good pressure, which can make for a lot of noise. Even at 60%
that is still a KW of heat out for 1500 watts out. Class AB1 for a
couple hours is the limit in winter. Class A, summer or winter is out of
the question.
A 4CX3,000 is really working and 1500 out Cass A is a lot more than the
dissipation than the tube is rated for.and that is really noisy!
With an Emtron DX-2sp running the legal limit with my voice
characteristics and a fair amount of processing, the blowers will kick
into high and the outlet air is quite toasty. (and noisy in this small
den. It's too many BTUs for this small den and it gets wayyy too
warm/hot in here in mid winter. Hence contest operation is strictly
from the shop. A 28 X 40' well insulated and open room with additional
heat in the winter and air conditioning in the summer.
As a comparison, I used to heat a 13 X 21' room and a 13 X 30' room in
the basement with a 4500 watt heater mounted in the wall. For class A
I'd really want a tube larger than the 4CX3000 and now we are getting
into tubes that take 500 to 750 watts just for the filament! <:-))
IIRC the 4CX3000 and larger do not show negative screen current. which I
understand (have read) is eliminated by the precision alignment, or
placement of the grid and screen wires.
I have to ask the more knowledgeable, if the negative screen current is
from secondary emission?
73
Roger (K8RI)
>
> Some tubes exhibit negative screen current, the 4CX1000A is known for
> that and it is normal under some conditions and right in the spec sheet.
> Many of the small 4X150 class exhibit negative screen current on VHF
> and if output doesn't increase when going positive it is OK.
>
> I get a small amount of negative with a 6M NCL-2000 while tuning but
> output always peaks in the positive 10-15ma region for 1200W. There is
> no negative with the HF NCL's unless it is a sudden downward drift
> signaling an impending BANG; this is a fairly common fault with 8122's
> that have been beat hard and misused. They often work OK in the CW
> position at the lower plate and screen voltages and are still linear.
>
> The AM-6155 I use on 432 and several of the AM-6154 and 6155's Ive
> converted or repaired for 144, 222, and 432 all show positive screens
> when loaded properly. The 8930 that is used is a 4CX250B with a bigger
> anode cooler and the Russian GS-36B/4CX400A is a direct replacement
> except for sometimes having to bend the plate cavity finger stock a
> hair; it performs the same.
>
> Carl
> KM1H
>
>
>
> --------------------------------------------------
> From: "Mike Waters" <mikewate at gmail.com>
> Sent: Tuesday, January 27, 2015 6:53 PM
> To: <amps at contesting.com>
> Subject: Re: [Amps] {Collins} Understanding Screen Current in a Tetrode
>
>> FYI, here was my post to the Collins reflector that prompted that reply.
>> What do you think?
>>
>> "There is a lot of misinformation out there about screen current. But
>> it's
>> the most important indication of proper loading!
>> "When I used to DX on the low end of 144 MHz with my homebrew 4X150A
>> amplifier (30 years ago), I knew that the amp was tuned just right
>> when the
>> screen current was either zero or very slightly negative.
>> "According to www.w8ji.com/loading_amplifier.htm : 'In grid-driven
>> tetrodes or pentodes the most important parameter is screen current,
>> with
>> control grid current a close second, and output power a close third.'
>> Believe it. :-) "
>>
>> 73, Mike
>> www.w0btu.com
>>
>> On Tue, Jan 27, 2015 at 5:51 PM, Mike Waters <mikewate at gmail.com> wrote:
>>
>>> Are you saying that we should always tune a grid-driven tetrode
>>> linear amp
>>> for the maximum screen current allowed by the manufacturer?
>>>
>>> Well, that would have been 30 or 40 mA on my homebrew AB1 grid-driven
>>> 4X150A amp. I think that would have been 30 or 40 mA too much! :-)
>>>
>>> It would be interesting to see what the people on the AMPS reflector
>>> have
>>> to say about this.
>>>
>>> 73, Mike
>>> www.w0btu.com
>>>
>>> On Tue, Jan 27, 2015 at 5:15 PM, David C. Hallam
>>> <david.hallam at knology.net
>>> > wrote:
>>>
>>>> For a GRID Driven tetrode amplifier, the correct way to tune and
>>>> load is;
>>>> apply dome drive and dip and load in the normal so that you have some
>>>> indication of resonance. At that point this is what you do. Keep
>>>> increasing the drive and adjusting the loading for maximum screen
>>>> current,
>>>> check the tuning occasionally. You keep doing this until you reach
>>>> one or
>>>> the other of two conditions. One, You reach the maximum screen
>>>> current
>>>> allowed by the manufacturers spec or Two, you have applied the maximum
>>>> drive you have available. Once you reach either of the two
>>>> conditions,
>>>> reduce the loading just slightly, and you will be properly loaded
>>>> for the
>>>> best IMD your setup will produce. I've been doing this for years
>>>> on my HB
>>>> linears with never a complaint about the quality of my signal.
>>>>
>>>> This is the point of the QST article.
>>>>
>>>> David
>>>> KW4DH
>>>>
>>>>
>>>> On 1/27/2015 4:45 PM, Tony Sokol wrote:
>>>>
>>>>> Hi Kurt,
>>>>> Good information because it backs up what I have been reading.
>>>>> EVERYONE tells you that monitoring the screen current is important
>>>>> but they
>>>>> really do not say what to look for or what to do about it. From
>>>>> reading the
>>>>> spec. sheet on the 4CX-1000A a comment is made that some tubes may
>>>>> exhibit
>>>>> a negative screen current as much as -25Ma. I did read that having
>>>>> the
>>>>> loading capacitor meshed too far will raise the voltages (and
>>>>> heat) in the
>>>>> tank circuit. I also have read that when the screen goes positive
>>>>> the IMD
>>>>> goes to pot and you start splattering. I guess the way to go is
>>>>> to tune up
>>>>> for max output with minimum plate current and then back off the
>>>>> loading to
>>>>> keep the meter at or under "0" screen current. As far as the screen
>>>>> current goes...positive is not good and negative (within
>>>>> reasonable limits
>>>>> ie. >20Ma) is nothing to worry about as long as the screen voltage
>>>>> remains
>>>>> stable. There was one other comment about dipping the screen current
>>>>> around "0" like you would with the plate meter I assume. I will
>>>>> try using
>>>>> that theory tonight on the net and see what happens. So far it
>>>>> seems to be
>>>>> running cooler and I had several unsolicited reports of "great
>>>>> sounding
>>>>> signal". With all of the 30S-1's out there I am surprised that we
>>>>> haven't
>>>>> seen more on proper tuning procedures for it.
>>>>>
>>>>> 73
>>>>> Tony - W9JXN
>>>>>
>>>>>
>>>>> On 1/27/2015 2:51 PM, W6ph--- via Collins wrote:
>>>>>
>>>>>> FYI, there is an excellent article about screen current on page
>>>>>> 26 or
>>>>>> July
>>>>>> 1961 QST. In the article it says that negative screen current is
>>>>>> not
>>>>>> unusual. But it also says that maximizing screen current (within
>>>>>> its
>>>>>> limit) is
>>>>>> the best indication of resonance. It also says that a tetrode
>>>>>> amplifier
>>>>>> should never be tuned for maximum output as is common for cathode
>>>>>> driven
>>>>>> (grounded control grid) amplifiers.
>>>>>> Kurt W6PH
>>>>>>
>>>>>
>>>
>> _______________________________________________
>> Amps mailing list
>> Amps at contesting.com
>> http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/amps
>>
>>
>> -----
>> No virus found in this message.
>> Checked by AVG - www.avg.com
>> Version: 2015.0.5645 / Virus Database: 4273/9007 - Release Date:
>> 01/27/15
>>
> _______________________________________________
> Amps mailing list
> Amps at contesting.com
> http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/amps
>
---
This email has been checked for viruses by Avast antivirus software.
http://www.avast.com
More information about the Amps
mailing list