[CQ-Contest] Unsportsmanlike conduct

[Eric Scace K3NA]

Hi Barry --

   You raised an interesting question which will likely stimulate many messages.  I disagree with your recommendation for the
following reasons.

   I didn't operate the contest, so I didn't hear what EO6F said on the air myself.  But I don't see where calling "CQ Contest No
USA" equates to unsportsmanlike conduct:

-- If he chooses not to work USA stations in the contest, his score suffers much more than the score of any single USA station.

-- EO6F broke no law or radio regulation.

-- EO6F broke no rule of the contest.

   You and others may not agree with EO6F's operating tactics, or his personal decision to operate the contest in a way that
reflects his personal concerns about the war.  But is this difference of views a matter that warrants consideration of
disqualification?

   To disqualify someone on the basis of "CQ Contest No USA" (or even something more polemic) can easily be viewed as a private
attempt at censoring what can, and can not, be said during the contest.  Freedom to express one's opinion is and freedom of assembly
with whomever one chooses are among the most basic rights in the USA's Constitution.

   Disqualifying a contester for saying "CQ Contest No USA" seems both petty and a poor reflection of the principles to which I hope
my country aspires.

73,
   -- Eric K3NA




-----Original Message-----
From: cq-contest-bounces at contesting.com
[mailto:cq-contest-bounces at contesting.com]On Behalf Of Barry
Sent: 2003 March 29 Saturday 11:15
To: cq-contest at contesting.com; K6AW at CQWW.COM
Subject: [CQ-Contest] Unsportsmanlike conduct


I noted, during the WPX contest, that EO6F was calling CQ CONTEST NO
USA, in protest of the ongoing war.
This is a real shame, as historically, amateur radio has pretty much
kept political differences out of the hobby.
I believe EO6F should be disqualified from the contest for his
unsportsmanlike conduct.  If you feel the same way, please email the
contest director (K6AW at CQWW.COM), as I have done.
73,
Barry--
Barry Kutner, W2UP              Internet: w2up at mindspring.com