[CQ-Contest] QSL Ethics question

[Paul Mackanos - K2DB]

Nope, NO QSL; not unless you worked and logged his personal call sign !!
Paul K2DB

-----Original Message-----
From: Bob Davis [mailto:bob at reconstructinghistory.com] 
Sent: Thursday, November 29, 2007 8:08 AM
To: CQ Contest List
Subject: [CQ-Contest] QSL Ethics question

Hi!

Here's a bit of an ethical question: I received a QSL request from a DX op
who was operating at a club station during CQWW CW. He's asking me to QSL
his personal callsign for awards use.  Is it "right" to confirm this QSO?
At first glance, I'm thinking, "No." After all, I have no way of knowing if
it was truly him at the key. Moreover, I was taught that the only valid
contact is one in which both callsigns are exchanged in their entirety.

Is my first-blush reaction the correct one? Or is this sort of thing done
all the time, and I'm just unaware of the convention?

Cheers,

Bob NQ3X

http://www.freewebs.com/nq3x

No trees were killed in the sending of this message. However, an
inconceivably large number of electrons was terribly inconvenienced.

P.S. Glad to work many of you during the test!  See you in January NAQP.