[CQ-Contest] CQ WW CW 2007 Result W2/NP3D - I just did not get it.

[Yuri VE3DZ]

LOGs are open now.
Download WB2AA's LOG and put it into your favourite Logger.
Calculate his P/Q ratio. Most likely you will find that Alex made more EU
QSO's than you...

73 Yuri  VE3DZ

P.S. maybe it's time to change ur call again? :-))


----- Original Message ----- 
From: "Andrei Stchislenok" <asnp3d at gmail.com>
To: "CQ-Contest" <cq-contest at contesting.com>
Sent: Sunday, September 02, 2007 1:22 AM
Subject: [CQ-Contest] CQ WW CW 2007 Result W2/NP3D - I just did not get it.


> Hello folks:
>
> With due respect to all.
>
> I received today September, 2007 CQ Magazine with the Results of CQ WW CW
> 2006 Contest.
>
> Just for curiosity, I compared two consecutive results on page 103:
>
> WB2AA result:
>
> 806,784 points  771 QSO's  95 Zones  289 Countries
> --------------------------------------------------------------------------
-------
>
> W2/NP3D result:
> --------------------------------------------------------------------------
-------
> 743,808 points  857 QSO's  99 Zones  285 Countries.
> --------------------------------------------------------------------------
-------
>
> These two stations have the same amount of mults = 384.
>
> W2/NP3D had 86 more QSO's than WB2AA; but he has almost 63,000 points
> less... (62,976 to be exact)
>
> Well, I have No problem with that, the (W2/NP3D) result is not that great
> anyway; that difference (62,976 points) just looks weird...
>
> Same amount of Mults, more QSO's, and less points... But whatever; this is
> not my point.
>
> My point is here:
> I opened my Writelog for the last year CQ WW CW and checked the numbers of
> what I claimed with what I found in CQ Magazine.
>
> What I saw, I just did not get it...
>
> I worked 883 QSO's - got confirmed 857  - lost 26 Q's or 3%
> I worked 104 Zones - got confirmed 99 Zones - lost 5 Zones or 4.9%
> I worked 294 Countries - got confirmed 285 Countries - lost 9 Countries or
> 3%
>
> So: I lost 26 QSO's and 14 Mults. Or I lost 3% of QSO's and 3.9% of Mults.
> OK
>
> My Claimed Score was: 874,160 points and Official result is: 743,808.
> --------------------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
------------------
> That means: I lost 130,352 points or 14.9 percents!?
>
> For 3 percents of lost QSO's and 3.9 percents of lost Mults I lost
> 14.9percents of points?? How nice...
>
> Strange Mathematic, Guys... I dont get it, sorry...
>
> But whatever... The Judge is always right. (something like that I heard)
>
> I never before even thought to analize all these numbers, feel just sorry
> that I opened my eyes at this time...
>
> Really sorry for this long story...
>
>
> -- 
> 73's Andrei
> EW1AR-NP3D
> WAS RTTY #455 (all via LoTW)