[CQ-Contest] Contest software

Pete Smith n4zr at contesting.com
Tue Sep 30 07:00:48 EDT 2008


At 09:51 PM 9/29/2008, Rick Kiessig wrote:
>Thanks to the many who responded to me directly...
>
>I should add a few things: first, I'm allergic to DOS-like programs;
>anything like that is a complete non-starter, which rules out CT, Win-Test
>and EI5DI.
>
>Second, I'm sure that any of the logger apps can do the job.  That's not the
>issue.
>
>Running down a list of what the current apps can't or don't do, or what I
>don't like about them isn't productive.  I'm not trying to get anyone to
>change anything.  I know that each app has its fans, and that's fine.
>Suffice it to say that I've found them all to be very quirky in one way or
>another.
>
>I was just wondering if there are (Windows-based, non-DOS) contest logging
>apps other than N1MM, WriteLog, N3FPJ and DxKeeper that I should consider.
> >From the responses I've received so far, I gather the answer is no.
>
>--Rick


The only other one I'm aware of is TR4W, a Windows port of TRLog, but it is 
very much a work in progress and still (last time I looked) lacking many 
features.

I think you're going about this wrong, Rick - you can't definitively choose 
a contest logging program by running down a features list or reading the 
manual.  Even to master *one* of the leading logging programs (and discover 
all it can or can't do) requires substantial time on the air, in a variety 
of contests, and interative development of an understanding of what it does 
in ways that you like, and in ways you don't.

I used CT for 5-6 years, TRLog for 8, and am into my 6th year with N1MM 
Logger.  I reviewed Win-Test and N1MM for National Contest Journal, have 
used Writelog in a major contest for a multi-2, and have tried TR4W, but I 
would not presume to tell you that I *know* any but N1MM Logger really well.

If I were you, I would pick the one that seems closest to meeting my needs, 
and plan to spend some considerable time using it and interacting with the 
user group.

73, Pete N4ZR     



More information about the CQ-Contest mailing list