[CQ-Contest] CQWW - considerations on the truths that are revealed

[W0MU Mike Fatchett]

It is common knowledge that there is a cultural desire to win at any 
costs and to bend or break the rules in other parts of the country.

Don't operate the contest if you think it is managed poorly.

W0MU


On 2/21/2017 1:24 PM, Alessandro Gromme wrote:
> Slowly the truth about the dubious management of what until now was
> considered the contest of the year coming out, bringing to light a
> "dubious" managemnet, not to call it "terribly unfair", by those who should
> ensure compliance with the rules, but which, it seems, the rules breaks
> first.
>
> It’s curious to find that several stations in recent years have been
> disqualified with ridiculous accusations, often were stations with an
> excellent result, for other charges that can be defined almost absurd.
>
> Often self-spotting appears to be a weapon in the hands of a  to the
> incorrect and dictatorial committee to remove from the final rank the
> stations thinking that the station accused cannot prove to be innocent but,
> even when the station produces concrete and irrefutable evidence of their
> innocence, nothing changes if not fall all in the silence, to not respond
> to emails and still confirm the disqualification.
>
> Now this is the procedure adopted by this Committee as the previous ones,
> is almost an unwritten rule that are handed down from management to
> management ... and this happens only in the CQWW !!
>
> Try to seek with a filter in the CQ WW database and see what he tells us?
>
>
> *CQWW SSB – United States (disqualified)*
>
> 2014 - N3IQ
>
> 1997 - KC6ETY/2
>
> 1986 - K3TUP
>
> 1980 - W6PU
>
> *Amazing !!! … in 37 years only 4 stations USA disqualified from thecontest
> !!!*
>
> I do not doubt there are really good operators .. but really only 4
> stations in 37 years have broken the rules, even slightly?
>
> mmmmm !!!!
>
>
>
> *CQWW CW - United States (disqualified)*
>
> 2015 - N0FW/8
>
> 2015 - W2YC
>
> 1995 - K1NG
>
> 1988 - N2GZL
>
> 1987 - WD5COV/0
>
> 1985 - AG2S
>
> 1983 - W2REH
>
> 1980 - W3RJ
>
>
>
> *Here definitely better right ?? ... I would say this ridiculous ... only 8
> stations disqualified in the last 37 years.*
>
> Not returning to the speech of the evidence or allegations that have
> disqualified ALWAYS foreign stations, often with a brazenness that justify
> himself behind ridiculous accusations, I wonder if this attention to
> disqualifications is impartial.
>
> I have been disqualified for 3 spot "doubts" of which I have given proof of
> being innocent (evidence, not words) ... in 37 years you want to tell me
> that no US station received 3 of dubious spot ?
>
> I do not want to create a diplomatic crisis between nations but if you want
> to make the champions of fairness we must with the same fairness and
> honesty to admit that this is suspect.
> _______________________________________________
> CQ-Contest mailing list
> CQ-Contest at contesting.com
> http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/cq-contest