[CQ-Contest] ARRL DX CW Results - Did Anyone Else Notice?

[Mike Fatchett W0MU]

Pretty simple.  It appears that KO1V violated CEPT rules.  Does IZ3EYZ 
now claim to reside in the USA as a resident?  It is possible that he 
violated both his licenses with this activation. W5OV- Since when does a 
DXCC country allow or disallow contest entries.  He operated under a 
CEPT agreement but does not live in the USA.  Correct.  Maybe IZ3EYZ 
needs to provide the legal proof that what he did was legal.  Is it any 
wonder that the ARRL is hemorrhaging memberships when staffers fly off 
the handle like this.  It is a very valid question.

W0MU

On 8/19/2023 6:49 PM, Randy Thompson wrote:
> I think it is a legitimate question. ARRL did accept the operation, but your response below doesn’t indicate that you had the proof either.
>
> We either accept the regulations for amateur radio in whatever country we are operating from or we accept that there are no rules.
>
> What does my arrl voice (whatever that is) have to do with this topic?
>
> Randy K5ZD
>
>> On Aug 19, 2023, at 7:40 PM, Naumann, Robert, W5OV via CQ-Contest <cq-contest at contesting.com> wrote:
>>
>> John,
>>
>> Please provide any proof that French St. Martin has disallowed this operation.
>>
>> If you have no proof, please stop making false accusations.
>>
>> This is not "My ARRL Voice" where lies are accepted without any proof.
>>
>> 73,
>> Bob W5OV
>>
>> ________________________________
>> From: CQ-Contest <cq-contest-bounces+w5ov=arrl.org at contesting.com<mailto:cq-contest-bounces+w5ov=arrl.org at contesting.com>> on behalf of John Crovelli <w2gd at hotmail.com<mailto:w2gd at hotmail.com>>
>> Sent: Saturday, August 19, 2023 12:56:19 PM
>> To: cq-contest at contesting.com<mailto:cq-contest at contesting.com> <cq-contest at contesting.com<mailto:cq-contest at contesting.com>>
>> Subject: [CQ-Contest] ARRL DX CW Results - Did Anyone Else Notice?
>>
>>
>> The 2023 ARRL DX CW results show FS/KO1A (IZ3EYZ) winning the SOAB Low Power category over VP2V/AA7V.  What caught my eye was a non-US citizen using a US/FCC issued callsign operating from a French possession.  Was that allowed under CEPT?
>>
>> I looked into this further.  Under CEPT Recommendation TR/61 as amended (https://www.arrl.org/files/file/Reciprocal%20operating%20forms/TR6101.pdf ) the CEPT rules specify an operator from a CEPT country must use the callsign assigned in his or her home country when invoking a CEPT authorization in a CEPT country. Both Italy and France are CEPT participants.  In this case TR/61 says using FS/IZ3EYZ would be compliant.
>>
>> USA CEPT rules (see https://www.arrl.org/cept) say a non-US citizen may use a US issued callsign only while operating in the US or from a US Territory.  IZ3EYZ is not a US Citizen yet he used his US/FCC issued call while operating outside the US (on French St. Martin).
>>
>> It seems highly unlikely the French Government granted him special authorization to use a US issued callsign on French Saint Martin in lieu of his Italian call.  He could have applied for a "TO" call and been totally legal.
>>
>> So the questions:  Was the use of FS/KO1A for this ARRL DX CW operation legal under US CEPT rules governing the use of a US issued call?   If not a legitimate use of his US call, should the operator have been awarded first place over VP2V/AA7V in the results?  If we agree use of an unauthorized callsign took place,  should the operation be assigned check log status or be disqualified under ARRL DX rules?   And one more question, should the contacts made with FS/KO1A be given credit under the DXCC program if the callsign was in fact unauthorized?
>>
>> Regards,
>>
>> John, W2GD/P44W
>> _______________________________________________
>> CQ-Contest mailing list
>> CQ-Contest at contesting.com<mailto:CQ-Contest at contesting.com>
>> http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/cq-contest
>> _______________________________________________
>> CQ-Contest mailing list
>> CQ-Contest at contesting.com
>> http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/cq-contest
> _______________________________________________
> CQ-Contest mailing list
> CQ-Contest at contesting.com
> http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/cq-contest