Jeff,

there may be a little bit more than meets the eye to this affect as well.

The article was written by several members of a club that suffered a narrow defeat for the small club gavel. (bad idea).  It would have been much more reasonable to have it written by a more objective author.

The contesting branch was in transition at this time and even they should have probably reached out to another source to get the feedback to write a more balanced publication. their summary of the club competition missed a number of important milestones of both the medium and small club categories.

I am avoiding the usual complaint that they simply do not capture information about contesting from the west coast, nor do they seem to really care but focus on the east coast big scorers.  A problem that I hope the new ARRL leadership will address as they fall into their new respective permissions (ARRL PREZ, and contest branch chair).

Just my 2 cents.  Thanks for being willing to reach out to these folks and let them know.

~Chris
N6WM





________________________________________
From: Mldxcc [mldxcc-bounces@contesting.com] on behalf of Jeff Stai [wk6i.jeff@gmail.com]
Sent: Wednesday, May 25, 2016 10:10 AM
To: k6lrn@arrl.net
Cc: MLDXCC
Subject: Re: [Mldxcc] We Won the Gavel!

So, because I write the ARRL RTTY Roundup article, I have a little insight.

The current (recently decided) editorial direction for QST is to print tables of results - top tens, clubs, etc. - photos, and text that doesn't necessarily speak to results but rather about the contest in general, conditions, and so on. Going forward you will seldom if ever see anything about the club awards in the printed version.

I am told this was based on reader response, not anything unilateral.

The online version has no constraints and can go on for pages and pages.

Sweeps is probably unique in that the club competition is split across two contests, and therefore two writeups done by two authors. Neither author really owns the club writeup, so therefore that portion was written by the "Contest Branch".

ARRL is all about participation. I'd like to think that they waxed on for three paragraphs about PVRC because they were able to get 300 logs submitted at an average 60K per log, not because of the proximity and familiarity to HQ. You can form your own conclusions...

That said I think the efforts of the MLDXCC to get 47 logs turned in - our average was over 84K per log - from our sparsely populated portion of California/Nevada are no less impressive. I'll write a note to the powers to that effect.

73 jeff wk6i


On Wed, May 25, 2016 at 9:30 AM, Dick Wilson <k6lrn12@gmail.com<mailto:k6lrn12@gmail.com>> wrote:
Yes, the only mention was one line in the staff comments in the on-line
article...like an after-thought.
Kinda discouraging...maybe we have to make an effort this year and,
maybe, just maybe we'll get two lines in '16 write-up.

Dick


On 5/25/2016 8:39 AM, Dennis Moore wrote:

The write-up on the November Sweepstakes doesn't mention anything about clubs, maybe they took that whole section out. It is nice to see us listed at the top of the club list in the medium category.

73, Dennis NJ6G

On 4/27/2016 10:42 AM, Robert Hess via Mldxcc wrote:
<http://www.arrl.org/files/file/ContestResults/2015/2015%20Phone%20Sweepstakes%20-%20Full%20Results%20-%20Version%201_03.pdf>http://www.arrl.org/files/file/ContestResults/2015/2015%20Phone%20Sweepstakes%20-%20Full%20Results%20-%20Version%201_03.pdf

I'm a bit annoyed that MLDXCC, and PL259 for that matter, got very little comment from the author.  It was all about PVRC winning the Unlimited Category.  Nevertheless, we as a club should relish in a terrific win and knocking off SCCC.

Congratulations to the little club that could!.

Bob
W1RH



_______________________________________________
Mldxcc mailing list
Mldxcc@contesting.com<mailto:Mldxcc@contesting.com>
http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/mldxcc
Need list help? Contact mldxcc-owner@contesting.com<mailto:mldxcc-owner@contesting.com>




_______________________________________________
Mldxcc mailing list
Mldxcc@contesting.com<mailto:Mldxcc@contesting.com>
http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/mldxcc
Need list help? Contact mldxcc-owner@contesting.com<mailto:mldxcc-owner@contesting.com>


_______________________________________________
Mldxcc mailing list
Mldxcc@contesting.com<mailto:Mldxcc@contesting.com>
http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/mldxcc
Need list help? Contact mldxcc-owner@contesting.com<mailto:mldxcc-owner@contesting.com>



--
Jeff Stai ~ wk6i.jeff@gmail.com<mailto:wk6i.jeff@gmail.com>