Topband: re : CQWW SSB & Our Continuing Bandplan Discussions....

[Michael Brown]

I think the only solution is for the Fcc to draw a line in the sand,
just like on all the other bands. Bandplans, gentleman's aggreements
just don't cut it. In cw and rtty contesting, in the big contests, 
these modes clobber the digital ops using other modes. I have
a low profile station here, and my 160 antenna is not going to
work Dx. So, I know I don't relate to some of the situations 
that other ops do that have excellent 160 setups that can work 
Dx on topband. If the FCC did a rule change that said cw and
digital from 1800-1870 (just an example) and phone from 
1870 and up, Dx transmitting low in the band we could operate
split, like we do on 40m phone contests, correct? Well, just
like Dennis Miller says, "just my opinion, I could be wrong". 
But I thought I would give it anyway.

73, Mike K9MI



----- Original Message ----- 
From: "Jeffrey Clarke" <ku8e1@yahoo.com>
To: <topband@contesting.com>
Sent: Thursday, October 18, 2001 11:10 AM
Subject: Topband: re : CQWW SSB & Our Continuing Bandplan Discussions....


> 
>  K1ZM wrote :
> 
>  To cut to the chase very quickly, I think it is fair to say that MOST
> of us are worrying MOST about what will likely happen if WE PERSONALLY
> make a sincere attempt to honor our new 160M bandplan by NOT
> transmitting below 1843kHz EVER during the contest (eg: you yourself
> follow the spirit of the bandplan) but THEN you hear others NOT doing
> so........eg: they are CQ'ing or calling MULTS below 1843.....
> 
> -----------------------------------------------------------------------
> 
>  While Jeff's ideas are really good, in the real world not everyone is
> going to follow them. There are probably going to be EU stations
> CQing and working other EU (and some USA stations who hear them)
> between
> 1820 - 1843. It's still OK to answer these guys down there but you
> run the risk of some guy operating CW complaining you trashed his QSO
> that you might have to deal with later. The odds are that if you keep
> your cool and don't start arguing with someone about the frequency you
> are not going to run into any problems with Riley. Remember this is
> just a band plan...The FCC regulations don't say you can't transmit SSB
> below 1843. Like Jeff said if you are in EU and have USA stations
> starting to call you, listen split above 1843. Also, a great idea by
> Jeff to suggest to M/M owners suggest to their 160 meter ops to limit
> their CQing above 1843....
> 
>                         Jeff  KU8E
> 
> 
> 
> __________________________________________________
> Do You Yahoo!?
> Make a great connection at Yahoo! Personals.
> http://personals.yahoo.com
> _______________________________________________
> Topband mailing list
> Topband@contesting.com
> http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/topband
>