Topband: May 2005 EET article about the DLM
W4EF at dellroy.com
Sat Aug 20 13:16:32 EDT 2005
----- Original Message -----
From: "David Gilbert" <rimradio at direcway.com>
> What you say is true, but I agree fully with Tom's comments on the
> slovenly work coming out of the U of RI. The early claims were simply
> ridiculous and unsubstantiated by mathematical analysis.
> In the first place, any technical acedemic who is too lazy to search the
> paper archives should probably find another vocation. More importantly,
> the lack of easy access to some of the older studies is more than offset
> by today's easy access to powerful modeling software. Even ten minutes
> in front of a computer running almost any version of NEC will
> demonstrate the near field strength parity of a 1/8 wave vertical versus
> a full 1/4 wave when both are over a perfect ground. The Navy's test
> results were a foregone conclusion and a big waste of somebody's time
> and our money.
> I can understand an individual like Vincent coming up with wild claims
> for the publicity of it. I have a harder time understanding how a major
> university goes along with it unless they simply don't know any better.
> Dave AB7E
Here is Vincent's biography:
As you can see, he is not a professional researcher, so
it is unlikely that anything he did got peer reviewed by
subject matter experts.
If you go to the EE department website for URI, you will
notice that the department is small and almost exclusively
focused on signal processing and VLSI:
It doesn't appear that they have any folks who specialize in
electromagnetics. Had this happened at a school like Ohio
State where the EE faculty is heavily focused on
electromagnetics and antennas, it might have raised some
eyebrows (at least I hope).
73 de Mike, W4EF................
More information about the Topband