Topband: One Way Propagation.

[Richard Quick]

Finally some common sense, thanks Luke!

Rich - W4RQ Amateur Radio: The Original Social Media

> On Jan 17, 2021, at 20:26, List Mail <mail10 at barefoothorse.com.au> wrote:
> 
> I have been using HPSDR in my station for the past ten or so years, and like Flex SDR, the S-meter does not change with application of attenuator. The signal strength changes between the transmitting antenna and receiving antennas of course, so IMO it's absolute value is largely irrelevant.
> 
> I also find somewhat bemusing the lengthy signal reports I hear between stations "with Preamp 1, with Preamp 2" etc., usually on 40 m SSB.
> 
> My on air reports usually pay little heed to what the "S-Meter" is reading, apart from noting the band noise strength compared with the signal strength. S-Meters are mostly a gimmick, with relevance only in laboratory bench testing. My use of the RST is generally in accordance with the verbal description of signals, i.e., Readability 1 = Unreadable to 5 = Perfectly readable; Signal Strength 1 = Faint signals, barely perceptible to 9 = Extremely strong signals. Don't start me on people giving "0 and 1 or 2" signal reports, and then conducting a conversation. And where the heck does the "Audio Only report, NO Signal strength" come from?
> 
> Back to the OT, I often receive very lopsided signal reports, usually with FT8 (sometimes a 30 dB lower report received than given) and less often in SSB or CW. Sometimes it is in my favour, sometimes my QSO partner. As long as we can complete our QSO, with a few of the traditional niceties, I don't lose any sleep over the differential. I live in a quiet rural location, with plenty of room for antennas, and the nearest neighbour is some 500 metres away, so I hear better than most. Sometimes I call a relatively strong station, and don't get any response at all, and wonder if my antenna has fallen down. I put it down to the other station listening in a different direction, and/or having QRM/QRN. I move on.
> 
> 73, Luke VK3HJ 
> _________________
> Searchable Archives: http://www.contesting.com/_topband - Topband Reflector