[TowerTalk] low band antenna without good ground

Alex Malyava alex.k2bb at gmail.com
Thu Sep 22 13:31:57 PDT 2011


Hi,
I need an advice for low band antenna (80-40) which does not need good
grounding system.
So far I have 30' Rohn 25 attached to the house with 2 element shortened
five-band beam on top of it.
I tried to set up an Inverted-L to be used on 80m without any luck. I just
cannot get meaningful impedance out of it.
The length of vertical part along the tower is 8 meters and horizontal -
going all the way to abandoned utility pole - was about 24 meters - longer
than needed for 80... The goal was to shorten it to something like 19...21
to get R=50 plus some X which gonna be compensated with capacitor... No way
- The R was all the way up to a 100, so I kept shortening it until I see
pure 50 ohm there.
I ended up with only 13m of horizontal part, X got compensated and whole
antenna had SWR below 1.5 at 3500....3650.
The thing is - half of EU station would not even answer my calls (100W) and
those who answer gave me reports of 369...559. It was not what I was looking
for.
I played with MMANA and yes, there is a resonance at 3500 for this length,
but R is only 13 ohm there... Where another 37 ohm are coming from????
It is too much for ground loss, isn't it? I managed to put 6 radials (3 in
each direction along the house) with a length of 12...15 meters - that's the
only space I have there... Where do you think I am getting 37 ohm from?
It would be really sad to dump it, but if there is no way to find/fix the
source of the losses - I will need to think about something else...
What kind of antenna I can use in that tiny space? Something which does not
need good grounding system - dipole? Lazy U? Anything multiband either by
design or with some sort of matching network at the feedpoint?
I have a picture of my "antenna yard" -
http://public.fotki.com/malyava/2010/30-mast/photo-12.html
It is shot along the property line... As you can see I have 6 feet wide
strip of land and the only high points there are 30' tower and wooden
utility pole 80 feet away.


Any ideas?

Thanks,
Alex K2BB


More information about the TowerTalk mailing list