[TowerTalk] Rotator loop - another question

[N4ZR]

In my old station, someone came up with this idea - instead of an actual 
loop, start with the rotator at mid travel and wrap at least two *loose* 
turns of RG-213 around the mast, then connect to the balun or 
feedpoint.  It worked fine with no problems in 20 years.

It seems to me that doing it this way provides physical support for the 
loop, which could be beneficial in high winds, but when I was putting up 
my current yagi, people working with me poo-pooed the idea, and so I 
wound up with the conventional loop.  It hasn't failed yet, but...

So, what's the informed opinion?

-- 
73, Pete N4ZR
Check out the Reverse Beacon Network
at <http://reversebeacon.net>, now
spotting RTTY activity worldwide.
For spots, please use your favorite
"retail" DX cluster.