[UK-CONTEST] RSGB 21/28 MHz Contest

[Dave Sharred]

I am not speaking as a committee member on this one, but wish to comment on
a couple of the thinks Mike said. I will leave that for an official
statement from the Chairman to do, or his secretary.

I am not sure why Mike thinks that we should tailor rules to suit him;  as I
remember Mike did have a respectable amp, so could well compete in the open
section should he chose to do so.

The 100W restricted section states 1 element per band, which seems to be
Mike's problem

If he chose to enter the QRP section (10 Watts), then he can use whatever
antenna he wishes; and probably do very well in it.

One of the problems in the structuring of restrictions for contests is that
the sections need to be designed to appeal to the most entrants.

1)   If you compete in the open section of a contest you are competing in
terms of power and antenna hardware

2) If you compete in the 100W section as in this contest, I personally
expect that the target audience is mainly those people with a vertical,
dipoles, trapped wire or doublet.   If you allowed someone with a 3 ele at
60' or better, which not everyone would have in this section, then you have
a distinct advantage

3) I have never felt comfortable with the QRP section, because then again, I
might expect that this is a subset of 2)   whereas it is in fact a subset of
1)

I would support leaving the restricted definition in place for this contest
(I would always prefer to enter the Open section anyway !)

73

Dave
G3NKC

-----Original Message-----
From: uk-contest-bounces at contesting.com
[mailto:uk-contest-bounces at contesting.com]On Behalf Of Colin G3PSM
Sent: 17 April 2006 11:53
To: Uk-Contest at Contesting.Com
Subject: Re: [UK-CONTEST] RSGB 21/28 MHz Contest




Mike Farmer (G3VAO) wrote:

<snipped>

>and whilst you are making sensible changes
>
I'm not making any changes Mike, just making a suggestion that the HFCC
may wish to do something with.

>how about a
>review of the restricted section - one of the principles of amateur radio
is
>to improve the performance of your station and I and many others have done
>this by staying at 100w and working on antennas - yet the RSGB places a
>handicap on us as we are required to compete against the boys running 400w
>(!!) - I believe that is contary to the principles of encouraging station
>improvements.
>
>
This is another suggestion they may wish to do something with, after all
most if not all members of the HFCC are members of this reflector.

73

Colin, G3PSM


_______________________________________________
UK-Contest mailing list
UK-Contest at contesting.com
http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/uk-contest