>I joined this list to learn about amp design, not repair.
It's a tough neighborhood here -- no doubt about it. However, I have
probably learnd as much about amp design from the hostile discussions as
much as the friendly ones. Make no mistake: I am not advocating hostility.
I'm simply stating a peronal observation.
I can see the
> point about not designing a fuse or limit resister in the grid circuit
> because it seems to be a band-aid for poor fault design. How do you
> justify
> designing it in?
I don't know whether or not grid fuses are appropriate in some amp designs,
but I will offer this answer to your question: Sometimes, the least complex
solution is the best compromise. While electronic grid protection may offer
the quickest response to a grid fault condition, the designer must design
the circuit in such a way that its failure causes no additional harm to the
amplifier above and beyond that caused by the underlying fault condition.
For example, if a switching transistor is used for grid protection, do we
have assurance from the designer that a collector-emitter short will not
cause additional harm to the amp? Is there even the remotest chance that
the circuit can fail and not provide 100% assurance of grid protection?
Some good electronic grid protection circuits do exist. But in terms of the
complexity/effectiveness ratio, I still ask this question: are most grid
failures the result of instant, excessive Ig, or sustained Ig? If a fused
grid protection circuit can be made effective in the design, is it necessary
to add additional cost, complexity, and additional potential points of
failure in the system?
By analogy, we could employ electronic current sensing on all our home
appliances. When AC current rises above a safe level, the AC circuit could
be made to immediately open rather than depend on a fuse or circuit breaker
to blow or pop. Notwithstanding UL and code issues, if a cruder method
(the fuse) is just as effective, less complex and less costly, is it right
to condemn the designers of all home appliances because they chose to use
fuses rather than electronic current-sensing switches?
Paul, W9AC
_______________________________________________
Amps mailing list
Amps@contesting.com
http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/amps
|