Jim,
I DID answer the question -- it simply requires some thinking based on
what I said. And what I said was not "opinion," it was a digest of how
things work.
FWIW, I didn't think much of your response either, but I was trying to
be nice.
BTW -- I know quite a bit about coax and stubs. Fifty years ago, I
taught a transmission lines course at DeVry, and a transmission line
matching method for broadbanding an 80M dipole was the subject of my
undergraduate thesis at the Univ of Cincinnati.
See k9yc.com/Coax-Stubs.pdf and http://k9yc.com/LocatingStubs.pdf
Nobel laureate K1JT heard my presentation of the material in the first
link at Pacificon several years ago and told me it was excellent. The
Power Point is also on the website. The second link was published in
National Contest Journal last year.
73, Jim K9YC
On Sun,2/21/2016 7:34 PM, JW via RFI wrote:
Jim Brown, the man asked a question which, so far, you have not made a reasonable attempt
to answer. The original subject was "RFI cured with 1/4 wave wire", less a
request for 'help' than a request for ideas on why this approach worked.
I did supply a reasonable hypothesis, and you disagreed, with little to no more
than opinion and hand wave. I am of the mind that perhaps you may not be as
studied or practiced with 'stubs' as some of us are, no matter the environment.
Please direct your attention to the question posed by the original poster. No
other plausible explanations have been presented that explain the first
poster's experience that I have seen, but, I may have missed something as I
have not received all replies on this subject.
_______________________________________________
RFI mailing list
RFI@contesting.com
http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/rfi
|