I just downloaded and skimmed Andrew's QEX paper from docfoc.com (google
found it).
Several things jump out at me. First, there is NO attention paid to the
ferrite material -- it appears to be assumed as ideal, with no loss.
Second, the fundamental property that makes a ferrite common mode choke
work is the LOSS coupled from the core and its resonance. This is also
ignored. Third, the core used in his experimental work was a Fair-Rite
#61 material. This is is rather high-Q material, so its resonance is
both narrow and difficult to measure. It is a VERY poor material for a
common mode choke in the HF range, for reasons noted in my tutorial.
Bottom line -- the analysis is far to simple, and thus is flawed.
73, Jim K9YC
On Wed,6/29/2016 9:09 AM, JW via RFI wrote:
re: ZS1AN's cascade
Are we talking ferrite loaded TLTs (transmission line transformer) or flux coupled
transformers and ferrite loaded "chokes" in his design?
I can never keep this current-voltage balun stuff straight.
de Jim WB5WPA
_______________________________________________
RFI mailing list
RFI@contesting.com
http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/rfi
|