Date: Sun, 9 Jan 2011 10:33:52 EST
From: TexasRF@aol.com
Subject: Re: [Amps] TWT Protection (was fuses)
To: gm3sek@ifwtech.co.uk, amps@contesting.com
Message-ID: <6c6e8.2ca3e207.3a5b2f60@aol.com>
Content-Type: text/plain; charset="US-ASCII"
Hi Ian, it is good to hear from you again and thanks for the information.
As you suggested, I am thinking that a second vacuum relay would be a good
solution to the problem. If it was wired to shunt a 50 ohm resistance from
cathode to ground, the 4400vdc supplied through the 500 ohm limiting
resistance would be dropped to 400vdc at the cathode while the shutdown
process
happens.
With the nice ham discount at Gigavac it seems quite unwise to not make
this improvement.
Since the added relay can be wired to switch the added resistor to ground,
a less expensive vacuum relay not rated for hot switching will serve well.
## IMO, the vac relay may well work better in that cro-bar mode...
VS say trying to open off the B+. That scheme, where the B+ is opened off
via a vac relay, that w8zr cooked up, and you see in Orr's last book,
[8877amp]
will work..abt twice. The eng I talked to at Kilovac said those cu contacts
on small
vac relays won't last at all..under fault current conditions, trying to open
off the B+
... with the typ 25-50 ohm glitch R.
He did say they would open off several amps of dc current....as in the amp is
off resonance,
and the plate current just drifted past it's pre-set threshold. [ IE: plate
over-current
trip point set for 1100 ma on a 8877].
## However, with tungsten contacts designed for hot switching a DC load, and
your 500 ohm
glitch R, your resulting fault current would be very low, and you could easily
open off the B+.
You could use both schemes, using 2 x sped up vac relays. You could also kick
the amp into
standby.
Jim VE7RF
An advantage of this method is that the fault sensing current would be
forced to a higher value to insure a more positive action in the event of a
less severe over current event. Such as when things go wrong and the helix
current runs high but an actual arc is not happening. This scenario is much
more likely than an arc.
At the price of hv fuses, only two or three events would pay the cost of a
new protection relay. So, this becomes a no brainer.
Thanks again for your input, it was just what I needed to reason through
the problem at hand!
73,
Gerald K5GW
_______________________________________________
Amps mailing list
Amps@contesting.com
http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/amps
|