A slight modification to what I said earlier:
If the fellow is in any way competitive with anybody, then a DQ is in order.
Doesn't need to be considered a violation of self-spotting rules for that to
happen: he's not using 160 meters in either CW or SSB modes (the only
permitted) to solicit contacts, which itself is a violation.
If he's just playing around and bears no threat to anyone, then a warning is
all that's in order.
Kelly
-----Original Message-----
From: cq-contest-bounces@contesting.com
[mailto:cq-contest-bounces@contesting.com] On Behalf Of Richard L. King
Sent: January-28-08 1:28 PM
To: n2ic@arrl.net; CQ Contest
Subject: Re: [CQ-Contest] Self-spotting, arranged QSO's and the CQ 160
contest
If you look at the rules for the CQWW 160M Contest, there is nothing
in the rules about self-spotting, etc. This might be an oversight.
Actually, the only thing that remotely addresses this action is the
following:
Use of packet, a spotting net, or logging assistance
makes an entry Multi-Operator.
I looked further, and didn't see any restriction about self spotting
in what I looked at and read on the CQ Magazine site. The rule above
might imply to some that the behavior is OK.
That being said, I don't think we can say that this was illegal or
unethical behavior if there was no rule against it. However, I will
agree with Steve that it is unacceptable for contesting. I think a
rule should be added to clearly prohibit this from happening and not
allow this form of self-spotting, even by multi-op stations.
The 160M Chat web site is there for coordinating weak signal work on
160M and it is used mainly by DXers. I don't watch it during contests
when I am single-op, unassisted. But I will watch it, without sending
it comments, when I am assisted or multi-op. To me it is no more than
watching packet.
I do think that any coordination of QSOs during contests is like
"self-spotting" and a rule should be added to cover it. Perhaps
something like, "Emails, Internet chat rooms, web cams that show
operating frequency, and packet self-spotting should not be used to
assist in the manufacture of QSOs for the CQWW 160M Contest by any
class of entry.
That's my opinion.
Richard - K5NA
At 16:32 1/28/2008, Steve London wrote:
>Here's an excerpt from the low-band chat room
>(http://www.on4kst.com/chat/start.php) over the weekend.
>
>Could someone explain to me how this could possibly be legal, ethical or
>acceptable behavior under the contest rules ?
>
>The call of the guilty party, a multi-op station owner, has been removed,
>although he certainly deserves to be outed.
>
>K4JRB, CQ 160 contest manager, I hope you are paying attention.
>
>73,
>Steve, N2IC
>
>2008-01-27 13:55:44Z larry bob--EU very good last night, worked 103
qso's
>2008-01-27 13:52:54Z larry gm bob
>2008-01-27 13:19:02Z larry calling on 19.5 for asia
>2008-01-27 12:46:56Z larry any VK on?
>2008-01-27 06:09:29Z larry nothing len, band was super earlier
>but nothing now
>2008-01-27 06:06:59Z larry i am listening but the band has gone
>flat, maybe
>soon at your sunrise
>2008-01-27 06:06:09Z larry thanks paul
>2008-01-27 06:03:42Z larry paul can you listen for me on 26.8?
>2008-01-27 04:59:07Z larry looking for EU on 26.6
>2008-01-27 03:04:02Z larry drago please spot me on 26.4, thanks
>2008-01-27 02:59:48Z larry bela please me es tnx drago qso
>2008-01-27 02:53:08Z larry looking for EU on 26.4
>2008-01-27 01:39:04Z larry sory alex i was not operating then. try
this
>morning again
>2008-01-27 01:36:51Z larry EU please lsn 26.4 and SPOT
>2008-01-27 01:19:52Z larry listen EU 26.5
>
>---------------------------------------------------------------------------
-----
>2008-01-26 07:50:19Z larry rag listen for me on 28
>2008-01-26 07:35:41Z larry no jim but LOTS of eu earlier
>2008-01-26 07:31:03Z larry calling EU on 28.0
>2008-01-26 06:50:07Z larry calling EU on 48.8
>2008-01-26 06:44:49Z larry 48.8????
>2008-01-26 06:41:47Z larry 39.5 busy here
>2008-01-26 06:40:09Z larry clear freq in EU?
>2008-01-26 06:19:31Z larry OK S& P now i am operating checking 34.1
>2008-01-26 06:17:26Z larry thanks braco QSL
>2008-01-26 06:16:35Z larry calling you braco
>2008-01-26 06:15:49Z larry OK worked the S52
>2008-01-26 06:14:32Z larry working a G4 qrx one
>2008-01-26 06:13:53Z larry another freq that is clear braco?
>2008-01-26 06:12:08Z larry listening for you branco
>2008-01-26 06:10:54Z larry still hearing EU, please call on 74.7
>2008-01-26 06:01:25Z larry thanks dick
>2008-01-26 05:59:22Z larry michael, thanks
>2008-01-26 05:57:05Z larry michael please spot me on the cluster,
thanks
>2008-01-26 05:56:05Z larry ivan operator change in 5 min will
>try window in
>15 minutes
>2008-01-26 05:54:04Z larry michael will try lower freq soon, thanks
for
>your help---still on 74.7
>2008-01-26 05:51:54Z larry andy OK try tomorrow
>2008-01-26 05:50:29Z larry andy, sorry no copy but still
>listening EU on74.7
>2008-01-26 05:48:04Z larry calling on 74.7 now!
>2008-01-26 05:45:59Z larry 1874.7?
>2008-01-26 05:44:37Z larry how is 49.0?
>2008-01-26 05:43:25Z larry trying to work CN qrx will check
>49.6 in a minute
>2008-01-26 05:39:14Z larry 26.9 busy and neg on om0m
>2008-01-26 05:36:11Z larry michael, 24 qrm here. another freq?
>2008-01-26 05:28:36Z larry an7 EU copy on 28.0?
>2008-01-26 05:26:41Z larry any EU copy on 28.0?
>2008-01-26 05:26:07Z larry any EU copy on28.0?
>
>_______________________________________________
>CQ-Contest mailing list
>CQ-Contest@contesting.com
>http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/cq-contest
_______________________________________________
CQ-Contest mailing list
CQ-Contest@contesting.com
http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/cq-contest
_______________________________________________
CQ-Contest mailing list
CQ-Contest@contesting.com
http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/cq-contest
|