Below are numbers I took from the ARRL results database. I think many
people have just made a blanket statements that there should be a distance
based points system without even looking over the numbers. Is this contest
really broken that changes need to be made ?
Contest
Total Entries
DX
W/VE
AS
AF
EU
OC
SA
2010 ARRL DX SSB
3175
1484
1691
231
22
972
53
144
2009 ARRL DX SSB
2668
1178
1490
159
17
740
45
142
2008 ARRL DX SSB
2128
812
1316
112
13
464
33
124
2007 ARRL DX SSB
2161
880
1281
134
13
547
29
102
2006 ARRL DX SSB
2221
940
1281
120
21
612
28
98
2005 ARRL DX SSB
2057
901
1156
144
15
556
31
94
2004 ARRL DX SSB
2267
930
1337
157
17
567
30
91
2003 ARRL DX SSB
2261
918
1343
179
11
530
29
118
2002 ARRL DX SSB
2286
964
1322
198
12
623
19
64
2010 ARRL DX CW
3938
2270
1668
384
21
1661
51
96
2009 ARRL DX CW
3131
1739
1392
277
25
1271
48
61
2008 ARRL DX CW
2686
1392
1294
208
16
1016
37
66
2007 ARRL DX CW
2569
1278
1291
191
28
916
29
68
2006 ARRL DX CW
2547
1363
1184
189
16
1035
27
44
2005 ARRL DX CW
2568
1381
1187
204
10
1040
21
55
2004 ARRL DX CW
2681
1383
1298
223
14
1004
35
57
2003 ARRL DX CW
2349
1226
1123
221
12
859
21
61
2002 ARRL DX CW
2384
1241
1143
261
15
874
19
36
Note :
1) Since 2002 participation is up for both W/VE and DX. I believe 2011
will be up too since propagation was good this year.
2) There are usually 5 times more EU entries than AS on CW since 2002.
3) There are usually 4 times more EU entries than AS on SSB since 2002.
4) Given that the east coast has the best propagation to EU and the
west coast to AS what type (fair) of algorithm do you use ? For example on
CW do you give the west coast 5 times more points for working EU and the
east coast 5 times for working AS. What do you do for the middle of the
country ? Do you cut that in half ?
5) Since there is more activity in EU than anywhere else will this even
make up the difference for someone not on the east coast ?
6) Could someone on the west coast make up the difference with the low
activity from JA ? I don't see where they would ever make 1/3 of the QSO's
to EU that someone on the east coast would.
7) If the ARRL went to a distance based scoring system for ARRL DX then
will this set a precedence for other ARRL contests ? After all ARRL
Sweepstakes isn't fair to those who are not in W5/W6/W7. When is the last
time someone on the east coast won SS ? (Especially SSB)
73, Jeff KU8E
_______________________________________________
CQ-Contest mailing list
CQ-Contest@contesting.com
http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/cq-contest
|