I've written on the subject of cheating in ham radio several times
before so I won't flog everyone here with the details, but suffice it to
say that many studies have shown why and under which circumstances
people are most likely to cheat ... and radiosport has ALL of them in
spades. I don't think there is any reason on this earth why we should
expect that hams represent a better class of people than the average
human, and for many people (not just hams) cheating *is* the contest ...
the thrill of trying to see if you can get away with it.
I'm not saying that we should let the rotten apples spoil things for the
rest of us, but I flat out guarantee that there are more than just a few
of them in our midst.
73,
Dave AB7E
On 1/30/2013 4:58 PM, w5ov@w5ov.com wrote:
Charly,
You've got a few years on me in this game, but I have been contesting for
40 years now, so I think I've got some "cred" when I generally disagree
with your summary.
I don't think there is nearly as much cheating going on as you seem to
think and I don't think that contesting overall is tainted. It is my
opinion that the vast majority are trying to obey the rules. If they
weren't, why would anyone bother with commenting on or being concerned
about what the rules are? I think the most controversial subject of
discussion here is contest rules, and especially when suggesting making
changes to them!
Even so, there are cheaters out there and the contest adjudicators do a
remarkable job in doing what they can to find them - given that they have
very limited access to the evidence that would be needed to do a 100% job.
W7DRA offered a very good insight with his comment that cheaters must be
able to consider what they do as "right" in their own minds, and for the
life of me, I cannot imagine how they can do that. I don't understand the
motivation of a cheater. While in Lance Armstrong's cheating, he was doing
so for fame and fortune, but we don't get much of the former, and none of
the latter in amateur radio, so what their motivation is, I haven't a
clue.
So, I would say that while there are going to be bad people in contesting
like there are in all other human activities, I don't think that there is
a majority of contest participants who are cheaters. To be honest, I think
the vast majority of people who are participants in contests are only
motivated because it's fun for them and they have no expectation of ever
winning anything. Granted, there are those who apparently derive some sick
and inexplicable joy from deceiving others, but I cannot let them ruin my
enjoyment of operating a contest. I'd encourage you do enjoy it, and not
be concerned with the few "rotten apples".
73,
Bob W5OV
_______________________________________________
CQ-Contest mailing list
CQ-Contest@contesting.com
http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/cq-contest
|