Friends,
I had to take this opportunity after the comment about the end of rare
sections...
I think all this remote work, trying to help J. etc is interesting and
wonderful and I really don't mean to be negative. But...what is the point of a
"rare section" if you don't have to be there to operate? Doesn't this in many
ways, miss the point of a multiplier?
As an analogous example, what if a DXpedition were to put up an automated
station in Bouvet, and operate it from home? Bouvet becomes common. What have
we really achieved? HF propagation to Bouvet was never really the point, was
it?
I'm not a Luddite, I get the interest, good intentions, and technical
achievement in all this. It sounds fun! But as a test to see if I was just
narrow-minded or a fuddy-duddy, I ran this remote idea past a few non-hams who
know just enough about contesting to understand. The comments I received were:
- That's bogus
- That's cheating
- You guys have lost your way
Can't say I disagree. Food for thought. Not to stop such operations, progress
will always move forward, but to try and recognize what it all means and
establish limits.
73,
Drew K3PA
-----Original message-----
From:Art Boyars <artboyars@gmail.com>
Sent:Wed 11-04-2015 09:21 am
Subject:[CQ-Contest] Who is this guy, really?
To:CQ-Contest Reflector <cq-contest@contesting.com>;
W1VE said: "Thanks to a lot of work from J and the remote team, Hal, W1NN,
will operate [VY1AAA] SOHP in November SS via remote from his home in Ohio."
OK, so "Hal, W1NN" will operate a NT station from his home in Ohio.
But for the past many contests "Hal" has purportedly operated "W1NN" in
Ohio ... remotely from Japan. (You could look it up.)
Can we believe that "Hal" is really where he says he is, or that the
station is where it claims to be, or even who he says he is?
(In case I'm too subtle, that was a joke.)
And Gerry will be (actually, physically) at K2LE in VT. Could that be
competition for W1SJ?
Are we about to see the end of rare Sections in SS? (Not a joke.)
73, Art K3KU
_______________________________________________
CQ-Contest mailing list
CQ-Contest@contesting.com
http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/cq-contest
_______________________________________________
CQ-Contest mailing list
CQ-Contest@contesting.com
http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/cq-contest
|