Pat and Allen and Denton....
What you are seeing is pretty normal, with the exception of the AGC
or the (rcvr) RF gain affecting the readings.
First it's helpful to realize that you are using ham equipment and
not commercial test equipment. The most accurate reading should be
the one in the rig, provided it was calibrated over the ham band
frequencies and you had a known good 50 ohm load connected directly
(and NOT through a piece of coax) to the rig's output coax connector.
Ham SWR meters are, in general, relative indicators, not absolute
indicators. Even the 'standard' Bird watt meters are spec'ed at +/-
5% and that is only with the meter indicating in it's mid-range. Most
hams connect the SWR bridge to their rig by using coax cable, which
definitely affects the accuracy of the reading. Even 'good quality'
coax cable have some inductance and some capacitance associated with
it's length. So even if you just use one foot of 'good quality' coax
between your rigs output connector and the SWR bridge, the rigs
indication, in most cases will certainly be different from the SWR
bridge's indicated reading. The other part of the equation is what do
you have as your load when your are measuring SWR? If you are using
your antenna for the load, the all accuracy bets are off, simply
because you really have no clue what impedance you are presenting the
SWR bridge and your rig.
The important thing is that you tune your tuner, or in the case with
no tuner, you adjust your antenna length, for minimum reflected power.
I think it would not be worthwhile to expect ham SWR bridges, no
matter who makes them, to read identical, in the same set up. Before
you get concerned that different SWR bridges do not read the same,
see if you can find any manufacturers specification for accuracy. IF
you can find those spec's, do they tell you at what load and at what
frequency are they giving you the specs.
What your after with ham gear is a reasonablly accurate (say, +/- 20
to 30%) SWR indication. I've never seen a 'precision' 50 ohm load
(meaning they cost around $600 bucks) for ham use, however they are
available for commercial use. Precision meaning 52 ohm +/-j0
certified across the frequency range of interest. And they are only
guaranteed to maintain their precision as long as they are never
overheated. Most ham test equipment will give you a good relative
indication, which is normally 'good enough' for ham use. Some
commercial and most microwave applications is where true accuracy is
required and that 'true accuracy' cost as much as ten times more that
ham test equipment.
Tom - W4BQF
At Wednesday 11:03 AM 8/9/2006, you wrote:
>Alan,
>
>Hello again. I have similar symptoms on the SWR meter on my OMNI VI+.
>With the RF gain at max the SWR meter will not go to zero but rests at
>about 2:1 SWR even though my 238 reads zero reflected. If I back the RF
>gain back to about 2:00 o'clock position it goes to zero as it should. I
>would like for it to read zero but don't know if there is an adjustment
>that would affect only that symptom without upsetting other ones. I just
>got the rig back from Ten-Tec last fall after repair and calibration. (I
>bought it in an estate sale and it had some problems.) I would have
>expected the service guys at T-T to have zeroed it if it was easily done.
>
>
>73,
>
>Pat
>
>
>On Wed, 9 Aug 2006 10:45:43 EDT ARDUJENSKI@aol.com writes:
> > I noticed that not in all cases will the meter (set to SWR) in the
> > Paragon
> > II read exactly the same as that is the 238 ATU. By the way the 238
> > and the
> > Paragon are connected by an 18 inch quality jumper (Belden 8214).
> >
> > I found a discussion on the topic in the ARCHIVES at
> >
>_http://lists.contesting.com/archives//html/TenTec/2003-01/msg00663.html_
>
> >
> >
>(http://lists.contesting.com/archives//html/TenTec/2003-01/msg00663.html)
>
> >
> >
> > Basically this section in short says to believe the meter in the
> > rig.
> >
> > SITUATION: I did notice that if I turn the AGC button to OFF the
> > meter will
> > match the ATU meter. (By the way I use a MFJ 249 Analyzer to find
> > the
> > settings for the ATU but find in some cases it still needs to be
> > tweeked when I
> > push TUNE.) Is this normal? I could not find anything in the manual
> > that even
> > mentions the AGC in conjunction with operation of the SWR/TUNE set
> > up.
> >
> > Is this normal or do I have a problem I need to look into?
> >
> > Thank you
> >
> > Alan KB7MBI
> > Woodinville, WA
> >
> >
> >
> > _______________________________________________
> > TenTec mailing list
> > TenTec@contesting.com
> > http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/tentec
> >
> >
>
>_______________________________________________
>TenTec mailing list
>TenTec@contesting.com
>http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/tentec
_______________________________________________
TenTec mailing list
TenTec@contesting.com
http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/tentec
|