TenTec
[Top] [All Lists]

[TenTec] Firmware 2.59d .... differing opinions should be solicited... d

To: tentec@contesting.com
Subject: [TenTec] Firmware 2.59d .... differing opinions should be solicited... don't you think?
From: Jerry Volpe <kg6tt@arrl.net>
Reply-to: kg6tt@arrl.net, Discussion of Ten-Tec Equipment <tentec@contesting.com>
Date: Sat, 04 Nov 2006 15:45:03 -0800
List-post: <mailto:tentec@contesting.com>
>> With all due respect Jerry, it's postings like yours that in itself
> tend to polarize the issue. By this I mean that your posting can be

seen to make a concerted effort to "debunk" firmware problem reports
made in good faith by knowledgeable users.  We all need to give a
little space to each other, and leave open the possibility that
there's some truth in what is being reported.

And your truth is the only truth? Unfortunately that is not my experience, nor is it the experience of a close friend who also uses an Orion... and finally version 2.059d. It is unfortunate that since I don't totally agree with some Orion related user findings that I must be 'debunking' those findings of other knowledgeable users. Have you considered that I may also be a knowledgeable user (I do have my EE in RF, analog, digital electronics with history as senior engineer in this industry.... 30 plus years experience... and an amateur operator for over 40 years)? Maybe what I was proposing was simply that in day-to-day operation and use issues which may seem very important to some may not be that important to others? ..... that perhaps it would be useful for each Orion owner to try for themselves. The reason for my 'polarizing' comment stems from the fact that regarding this particular reflector it seems virtually impossible to express an opinion that somewhat differs from certain outspoken individuals without having the 'facts' presented once again.

Please don't think that Ten-Tec engineers do not periodically review this and other Ten-Tec related reflectors you. They do. But simply posting reflector comments and suggestions, regardless of the posting individual's level of commitment and belief, does not guarantee that others fully agree or that there isn't more to that story. Perhaps it is merely a matter of timing?

If 2.059d is so horrible then why are many Orion owners enjoying it every day? I have access to all the firmware versions and I spent some time testing the later versions of 1.3x. There were definitely things that I liked as well as things that I didn't. The same with version 2.059d. However, Ten-Tec is not going back to the version 1.x code base for future firmware development, so any future changes will be based on the current 2.x versions. My personal decision was to commit to using what they are working with and working on. That way, to my thinking, what ever I do experience will be more directly useful. And as I stated, I enjoy the Orion as configured with 2.059d more than I did under the version 1.x firmware choices.

Finally when ever I see the words "with all due respect" I know that there is none... and that is too bad.

--
Ralph Jerald "Jerry" Volpe
Amateur Radio Operator KG6TT
ARRL Member & VE
FISTS 12304

788 Chestnut Drive
Fairfield, CA 94533

kg6tt@arrl.net

510 325-7724
707 399-8838 FAX


<Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread>