Hi all,
Great topic! Each gear setup is designed for a specific load/relative
surface velocity in order to give good service. Spur gears can be run
in the open at very low velocities with zero lubrication due to the
mainly rolling, not sliding motion between two properly contoured
gears. Of course, neglecting bearing drag, spur gear systems have
extremely low resistance to back driving at all, even in high ratios.
If you are using a spur gear winch without the brake engaged, watch out
for the drive handle when it starts to spin, it can be back-driven to
extremely high rpms and cause you damage!
Due to the sliding motion of worm gear systems, they rely on lubrication
to achieve good functionality. For a reference relative to this
discussion, you can see my white paper at:
http://zddplus.labecon.com/TechBrief11%20-%20Internal%20Combustion%20Engine%20Lubrication.pdf
Although the paper is largely about internal combustion engines, in
particular study the Stribeck Curve on page 2. The advantage which worm
gears have over spur gears is specifically the high resistance to back
driving due to the lead angle and contact area, which I'll explain in a
bit. When run above critical speed with adequate lubrication, worm
gears will operate in a hydrodynamic lubrication regime and as such will
be very low friction, with the remaining drag due solely to viscous
shear of the oil film. Running worm gears without lubrication, or at
very low speeds with insufficient lubricant viscosity will shift the
operating point of the gear system to the left on the Stribeck Curve,
increasing asperity contact, friction and wear. This is why antenna
rotators which use worm gears powered by a relatively high rpm electric
motor can see long service with little wear, the high surface speed
shifts the lubrication mode as seen on the Stribeck Curve to the right
into the hydrodynamic regime. On the other hand, a worm gear hand winch
with it's intermittent and very low speed would have to use extremely
thick grease in order to achieve this condition under load.
The high resistance to back-driving which worm gear systems display is
due to this differential friction characteristic of driven vs
back-driven interacting with the lead angle. The lead angle is
determined by the pitch of the teeth and diameter of the worm, and the
higher the lead angle the lower the friction and resistance to
back-driving. When driving the worm at high speed the system is in a
low-friction hydrodynamic regime with attendant low wear. When
back-driving, there is very high pressure at zero velocity and resulting
high friction which is an advantage in many applications and will cause
no wear...until the combination of force and lead angle induce
movement. Then the wear can be extreme.
Take home message: worm drive systems do not have high friction when
operated correctly, and lubricant viscosity is not a user choice: it is
a design variable in any system, and the manufacturer's recommendations
should be followed.
Howie - WA4PSC
www.proaudioeng.com
_______________________________________________
_______________________________________________
TowerTalk mailing list
TowerTalk@contesting.com
http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/towertalk
|