On 6/3/13 6:32 AM, John Geiger (AF5CC) wrote:
I had previously said that I had a G5RV type dipole that I made
myself. After repairing it today following a run in with a tree
branch last Wednesday, I realize that it isn't quite that. It is
more of an "off center fed dipole". It isn't the classic "Windom off
center fed" where one leg is twice as long as the onther. On my
antenna one leg is approximately 50 feet long, and the other leg is
around 60 to 65 feet. It is fed with 300 ohm radio shack twin
lead-about a 25 foot run, which goes to a 4:1 voltage balun, and then
to 75ohm RG-11 coax to the shack.
Given this new revelation, that it is a off center fed dipole, what
is now the best balun for the twin lead to coax junction? I am
assuming that it isn't quite a balanced antenna, since the legs
aren't equal, so how crucial does a balanced to unbalanced (coax
feedline) transformer become? My main interest is trying to keep the
RF off of the coax shield, although I haven't had any real problems
with RFI in the shack.
You've got two separate issues going on here: one is that an OCF dipole
has a feedpoint impedance that's higher than a center fed. So you
probably want some sort of transformer. You'd have to model your
specific lengths and feedpoint position at the frequencies you operate
at to find what ratio you want. 4:1 and 9:1 are common, because the
first is a 2:1 turns ratio transformer, the second is 3 turns on the
High Z side and 1 turn on the Low Z side.
Do you have a way to measure the antenna Z?
The other is that the asymmetric antenna will tend to induce currents on
the ouside of the feedline (or common mode currents on a balanced line).
As a practical matter, most symmetric dipoles have this problem too:
rare is the installation in the middle of a perfectly open field for
100s of meters on every side with the feedline perfectly symmetric to
the dipole elements on a windless day.
The common mode/outside the coax current issue has an easy fix: choke it
by making a lossy inductor with the right cores (31 mix is favored for
this application).
you do NOT want to use the same kind of core for the transformer as for
the RF choke. The RF choke core should be one that shows a lot of loss:
the exact wrong choice for the transformer core.
_______________________________________________
_______________________________________________
TowerTalk mailing list
TowerTalk@contesting.com
http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/towertalk
|