[CCF] [TOEC] Russian DX Contest 2011 - Rules

[Jan Erik Holm]

Mats,

Yes of course no problem, you are just the messenger I do understand
that.
Well yes I saw the QRP rules also, I could speculate why they want
those changes but I will not do that.
In any case, 36 hours is all the same, 1 hour 36 or whatever isn´t
really important but to force people using "CAT systems" that is too
much.
Now, they can make the rules any way they want and there is still
going to be enough people participating however in this case for
me this is too much and too silly. I park my radio and rest my case.

I my opinion there are things in radio contesting that are far more
important however that would be a different subject.

Jim SM2EKM
-----------------------
On 2011-02-11 11:13, Mats Strandberg wrote:
> Hello Janne!
> I kind of agree with you that some of those changes are perhaps an
> overkill...
> My info was just meant to be a reminder of a nice contest - not a
> support for any new rules :)
> There is also an issue regarding LP and QRP stations that I found a
> little "foggy"...  Could not really figure out why just those categories
> should start mentioning coax type, coax length, height above Sea Level
> of the QTH etc...    ASL elevation according to my understanding is not
> telling anything at all...   A 20 meter high antenna 5 meters from the
> Indian Ocean (20 meters ASL) can work a hundred times better than the
> same type of antenna, 4 meters above ground level) at 5000 meter ASL in
> a deep valley of Himalaya, surrounded by 3000 meter higher peaks...
> I informed my Russian colleagues about those things - we will see if any
> reactions come ;)
> 73 de LRR
>
>
> 2011/2/11 Jan Erik Holm <sm2ekm at telia.com <mailto:sm2ekm at telia.com>>
>
>     Not that I planed to take part and if I would have I don愒 know
>     if I would make top 3 however these rule changes will completely
>     rule me out.
>
>     It愀 a free choice and this one is not worth the cost of electricity
>     any more.
>
>     Jim SM2EKM
>     ................
>     11.11 High scores pretending to be in the top 3 list of any contest
>     category must indicate exact frequency of every QSO made (CAT system
>     use).
>
>     11.11.1 An applicant will not be able to claim a spot in the "Top 3"
>     places of any category unless exact frequency of every QSO made is
>     indicated.
>
>     12.2 An applicant aiming for a spot in the "Top 3" list of any
>     contest category (paragraph 3, 3.3) must submit his logs within 36
>     hours after the end of the contest.
>
>     12.2.1 An applicant will be denied a spot in the "Top 3" of any
>     category if his log was submitted later than 36 hours after the end
>     of the contest.
>
>
>     -------------------------------------------------------------------------------
>
>
>     2011-02-11 09:41, Mats Strandberg wrote:
>
>         Hello!
>
>         High time to prepare for the 18th edition of the Russian DX
>         Contest, taking
>         place on March 19th-20th (1200-1200 UTC).
>
>         Some new rules have been added -
>         http://www.rdxc.org/asp/pages/rulesg.asp
>
>         Nordic participation increased significantly last year and it
>         would be nice
>         to continue in the same direction this year.
>
>         73 de R3/SM6LRR, Mats
>
>